Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
(Mis)Reading NatalieThe Viewer’s Cognitive Processes and the Unreadable in Christopher Nolan’s Memento Katherine Weese (bio) Analyzing the narrative structure of Christopher Nolan’s Memento (2000), Stefano Ghislotti writes that “of all the issues raised by the film, one of the most intriguing is that concerning the viewers’ mental activity: how one can cope with a film so intricate and difficult to understand is a very stimulating question” (2009: 87). When I teach this film in an introductory cinema class, I have repeatedly observed an interesting phenomenon in my students’ attempts to cope with the film’s challenging narrative about Leonard Shelby and his associates Teddy and Natalie: many of them conclude that Natalie—a neglected character in critical interpretations of Memento—deliberately sets Leonard up to kill Teddy as an act of revenge against Teddy, who arranged for Leonard to kill Natalie’s boyfriend. This impression of Natalie, belied by evidence scattered throughout the film, is fostered by the film’s arrangement of the story events, and not only my students but also more experienced viewers have drawn [End Page 101] the same conclusion. Cognitive narrative theorist Lisa Zunshine’s (2006) work on theory of mind partially illuminates what takes place as viewers of Memento struggle to understand Natalie’s motives and to explain her role in the chain of events that leads to Leonard’s killing Teddy. But discerning the intentionality of the characters in this film is complicated by the way the film’s episodically reversed narration approximates in its viewers the memory problems experienced by Leonard, who has suffered brain damage and anterograde amnesia when he and his wife were brutally attacked by intruders in their home. Research on attribution theory described by Marisa Bortolussi and Peter Dixon (2003) extends our understanding of viewers’ tendency to misconstrue Natalie’s motives, as do studies undertaken by neuroscientist Michael S. Gazzaniga (2005, 2008), who hypothesizes the existence of what he calls “the left-hemisphere interpreter,” a region of the brain that creates cause-effect relationships on the basis of partial knowledge. Memento’s complicated narrative structure invites its viewers to narrativize puzzling parts of the story, and cognitive approaches such as Zunshine’s, Bortolussi and Dixon’s, and Gazzaniga’s account for viewers’ processes in their struggle to comprehend Natalie’s motives. Indeed, many of the film’s critics adopt a cognitive approach in their analyses, though they have focused on the difficulties of recovering Leonard’s backstory rather than on the difficulties of reading the character Natalie (e.g., Parker 2004, Renner 2006, Jackson 2007, Owen 2008, Ghislotti 2009, Gaut 2011, Dancygier 2012). While Gaut contends that viewers can definitively reconstruct the story (2011: 26, 31–43), other critics, such as Spicer (2007), Kania (2009), and Little (2005), stress the film’s unresolved ambiguities that result from its unusual narration. In its elements that defy the reader’s sense-making strategies, the film can be considered an unnatural narrative as defined by proponents of unnatural narratology—it is a text that resists viewers’ tendency to account for puzzling elements in terms of the mimetic contract, to understand them according to experiential, real-life parameters and thereby reduce their strangeness and interpretive recalcitrance. An unnatural narrative, according to its principal theorists, Jan Alber, Stefan Iversen, Henrik Skov Nielsen, and Brian Richardson, depicts events that are physically impossible and/or employs an impossible narrative perspective; [End Page 102] these “physically, logically, mnemonically, or psychologically impossible enunciations” (Alber et al. 2010: 124) often violate narrative conventions described by classical narratologists, which pertain mainly to mimetic narratives. Unnatural narratology thus “differs from both classical structuralist and standard cognitive narrative theory” (114). For example, Memento complicates the distinction in classical narrative theory between story and discourse when we are given Leonard’s and Teddy’s incompatible versions of what happened to Catherine with no clear way to resolve the differences, “no retrievable fabula” (Richardson 2011: 26). The film’s unusual treatment of time further challenges classical narratological considerations of temporality advanced by Gérard Genette (1972/1980), which are later revised by Richardson’s exploration of postmodern experiments in temporality (2002). Hansen (2011) provides an extended discussion of Memento...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Katherine Weese (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: