Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Insecticide-treated materials and particularly mosquito nets treated with synthetic pyrethroid insecticides (insecticide-treated net, ITN) as a tool in malaria control had received renewed interest some two to three decades ago (Lindsay & Gibson 1988). During the 1980s, a number of small-scale studies had demonstrated significant reductions in malaria morbidity associated with ITN use in different African, Asian and Latin American populations (Rozendaal 1989; Bermejo & Veeken 1992). Subsequently, three large randomized controlled ITN efficacy and one effectiveness trial have been conducted during the 1990s in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). These trials have consistently demonstrated the efficacy of ITN in reducing malaria morbidity and mortality in young children over a broad range of malaria transmission intensities (Lengeler 1998; Phillips-Howard et al. 2003). Thus, ITN are considered the most efficacious, currently available intervention for malaria control (Whitty et al. 2002; Hawley et al. 2003a,b). This should, however, not impair the overriding importance of treating all malaria patients early with an effective drug preferably as combination therapy (Guerin et al. 2002). The ITN were already employed on a large scale since the 1980s in many malaria endemic areas of Asia, where they have contributed to major successes in malaria control (Hung et al. 2002). Despite some remaining uncertainty about using ITN in the high-transmission areas of SSA with regard to long-term effects on young children's immunity and subsequent morbidity and mortality rates, the need for a large-scale introduction of ITN in SSA is now well accepted in the scientific community as well as among international agencies (Whitty et al. 2002; WHO 2002; Curtis et al. 2003; Hawley et al. 2003a; Lines et al. 2003). However, due to major differences in infrastructure, public service organization, funds and epidemiology, progress in the implementation of ITN intervention in SSA was comparably slow. Today, only some 2% of children in SSA are protected with ITN (WHO 2003). So what is now the best strategy for expanding ITN coverage in SSA? Two approaches are competing with each other in the international debate. The first group argues to consider ITN as a public good like vaccines and to consequently provide them through the public sector free of charge (Curtis et al. 2003). In contrast, the second group argues for strengthening commercial markets while acknowledging the importance of subsidies for the groups most at risk, e.g. pregnant women and young children (Lines et al. 2003). The group in favour of free distribution of mosquito nets and insecticide supports their argument by the evidence from a few East African pilot projects regarding the feasibility of such an approach, the existence of a significant community effect in most areas with high ITN coverage, the reality of a high proportion of the rural populations in SSA being unable to pay for such an intervention, and the hope that rich countries would be willing to pay for malaria control in SSA (Curtis et al. 2003). However, the group in favour of primarily strengthening commercial markets supports their argument with promising experiences from a large ITN social marketing programme in rural Tanzania, the important role of market involvement in the success of ITN programmes in Asia, the assumption that universal coverage with free ITN would destroy local commercial markets, and the uncertainty of continuously available foreign funds for ITN programmes. There is, however, considerable agreement in both groups regarding the need for major donor assistance for whatever approach (Curtis et al. 2003; Lines et al. 2003). In our view, these two strategies for expanding ITN coverage in SSA are not mutually exclusive. As pregnant women and young children are clearly the two groups most at risk for malaria morbidity and mortality in most of SSA, we believe that the focus of ITN programmes should be on these two population groups. Given the high coverage of antenatal care (ANC) services in most of SSA, these services provide a unique opportunity to reach the malaria target groups (Hamel et al. 2001). The provision of free ITN through ANC services to all pregnant women would significantly contribute to reductions in the rates of maternal morbidity, placental malaria and low birth weight children, and consequently reduce maternal and infant mortality (Dolan et al. 1993; D’Alessandro et al. 1996; Ter Kuile et al. 2003). Moreover, the provision of ITN through ANC services is expected to strengthen these services and to give their counselling on malaria prevention more credibility. Finally, the provision of ITN would likely attract more women to ANC services and may thus provide additional health benefits to this important target group (Fraser-Hurt & Lyimo 1998). After birth, the youngest children and thus the group at highest risk for malaria mortality would automatically be protected while sleeping with their mothers under the ITN. There is furthermore convincing evidence for social marketing being effective and cost-effective for distributing ITN in SSA (Armstrong-Schellenberg et al. 1999; Hansen et al. 2003). As a large-scale distribution of ITN through ANC services combined with free insecticide treatment in communities will likely increase the demand for this intervention in the general populations of SSA, combining free distribution of ITN to pregnant women with increased promotion and sale of such products in the private sector with or without subsidies should be the way forward. So what about ITN re-impregnation with insecticide? Re-impregnation is needed in certain intervals due to the loss of insecticide over time, which is mainly influenced by washing frequency (Lines 1996a). Thus, re-impregnation services will need to be provided to assure continuous protection of children throughout their early life and until they have developed their own immunity. Such services should be free of charge as otherwise coverage will be very low as demonstrated in many ITN projects in SSA (Lines 1996b; Cham et al. 1997; Armstrong-Schellenberg et al. 1999; Kachur et al. 1999). Re-impregnation services would need to be organised once or twice a year (depending on local epidemiology) by the public health services together with respective village populations. In our view, re-impregnation should be provided not only to families who received ITN through ANC services but also to all families who wish to have their mosquito nets treated with insecticide. Such an approach would likely support the acceptance of the ITN programme in communities and would furthermore increase the community effect of ITN (Howard et al. 2000; Maxwell et al. 2002; Hawley et al. 2003b). If technical progress leads to the future availability of reliable long-lasting insecticide treatment, ideally lasting the entire lifetime of a mosquito net, re-treatment services may no longer be needed. However, the efficacy of currently available long-lasting ITN prototypes has not been convincing under field conditions (Müller et al. 2002a). So what is the evidence for the feasibility of combining public and commercial strategies for ITN promotion? Initial evidence comes from the National Impregnated Bednet Programme in The Gambia, a country with a traditionally high prevalence of mosquito net use (D’Alessandro et al. 1995). During the first year of this programme villagers were offered insecticide free of charge through their respective village health workers, while during the second year the insecticide was sold at a price of US$ 0.5. The introduction of fees for service was accompanied by a sharp drop in impregnation coverage from 85% during the first year to only 14% in the second year (D’Alessandro et al. 1995; Cham et al. 1997). Cost-recovery was introduced into the whole country during the third year of the programme, and communities were offered insecticide again through village health workers but alternatively also through shops. In addition, women attending selected mother and child health (MCH) services were offered insecticide free of charge. An evaluation of the activities of the national programme during its third year provided evidence that offering insecticide through private channels led to increased impregnation coverage, and showed that providing insecticide through MCH services is effective in targeting young children (Müller et al. 1997). These findings are furthermore supported by our experience from an ongoing ITN effectiveness trial in 41 villages of rural Burkina Faso, where all newborns and their mothers are provided with free ITN and free annual re-impregnation (Müller et al. 2002b). This trial is now into its fourth year and coverage and re-impregnation rates have remained above 90%. As reported from other pilot projects with free provision of ITN, we also have no indication for ITN being sold or diverted (Curtis et al. 2003). Moreover, we recognized a demand for community-based ITN sale and re-treatment services in this rural area of Burkina Faso (Okrah et al. 2002). Based on the current UNICEF bulk price for nets of US$ 1.40 each, it has been calculated that US$ 295 million per year would be needed to provide comprehensive ITN coverage to all households in the malaria endemic areas of SSA through free nets and insecticide (Curtis et al. 2003). These calculations have been criticized as being not well founded and still too high to be covered by the Global Fund for AIDS, malaria and TB (Lines et al. 2003). However, providing ITN free of charge only to ANC services combined with free insecticide treatment of all mosquito nets in the community would be considerably cheaper and thus more sustainable. If we consider a need for purchasing some 25 million mosquito nets for pregnant women together with insecticide for an estimated 100 million treatments per year in SSA, material costs would be limited to some US$ 85 million per year. Such an amount of funds should clearly be available through the Global Fund if the international community is willing to take the issue of malaria in Africa seriously (Teklehaimanot & Snow 2002). In conclusion, we believe that in view of the prevailing poverty in most of rural SSA, giving pregnant women and their young children ITN free of charge, plus free insecticide for all existing mosquito nets in malaria endemic communities would currently be the best use of available funds besides supporting other malaria control interventions such as combination therapy. This would need to be complemented by appropriate support to the private sector (e.g. social marketing approach) to achieve even better coverage with mosquito nets in SSA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Müller et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: