Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper reviews existing approaches to assessing tourism sustainability, especially its contribution to climate change. It assesses ecological footprint analysis, environmental impact assessment and input–output analysis but finds them inaccurate and unreliable. It goes on to argue that life cycle assessment (LCA) is a more promising tool for tourism climate change impact assessment, highlighting important areas where LCA application can contribute towards better understanding of tourism's role in global climatic changes. To demonstrate the applicability of the LCA methodology, a case study of a short weekend holiday trip is presented. Related greenhouse gas emissions are measured comparing LCA and alternative carbon footprint calculation methods. The comparison demonstrates markedly different results. The reasons for the discrepancy along with the potential of LCA to estimate the "indirect" carbon contribution of the holiday trip's components are discussed. A key feature of the LCA calculation is that for short-haul trips the proportional impact of accommodation-related emissions is shown to be larger than in earlier calculations, while transport impacts are reduced. 对旅游气候改变评价方法的批判性论述: 以生命周期评估为新途径 该文章回顾了现有的评估旅游可持续性的方法, 特别是这些方法对气候改变的贡献。文章评估了生态足印分析法(EFA), 环境影响评估法(EIA)和输入输出分析法(IOA)。但是发现这些方法不正确也不可靠。文章继续辩驳生命周期评估法(LCA)对旅游气候改变影响的评测是一个较有效的工具。因为LCA的使用能有助于更好地理解旅游在全球环境改变中的职能。为了更好地解释LCA方法的运用, 文章用了一个短期周末度假的案例。通过对比LCA和其他的碳排放计算方式, 相关的温室废气排放量被测试了。对比说明了非常不同的结果。差异的原因和通过LCA能估测度假中间接碳排放量的问题都有讨论到。LCA方法的特点是对短程旅途而言, 住宿引起的废气排放量相对以往的计算方式比例上要来得大, 而交通引起的却少。 Keywords: sustainability assessmentcarbon footprint analysislife cycle assessmentclimate changeholiday packageKeywords: 可持续性评估二氧化碳足印分析生命周期评估气候变化假日组成部分 Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to two anonymous reviewers whose comments have significantly improved the quality of this contribution. Notes 1. Holiday travel consists of (1) transport (further subdivided into transport to/from the airport at the country of origin, transport to/from the destination and local transport at the destination), (2) accommodation and (3) activities (further subdivided into activities, entertainment and attractions) (CitationBecken & Simmons, 2002). Some authors also include food consumption (CitationGössling et al., 2002) and waste generation (CitationPatterson et al., 2007; CitationPeng & Guihua, 2007) into holiday travel components. 2. Note that the estimates of the contribution of tourism air travel to the global anthropogenic GHG emissions are quite uncertain. Today the figure of 3.5% is widely used as a share of the man-made greenhouse effect associated with aviation (CitationGössling & Peeters, 2007). However, some authors challenge this since it does not consider the uncertainty imposed by the radiative forcing coefficient (CitationGössling & Peeters, 2007). The radiative forcing coefficient weights the GHG emissions of air travel with a factor of between 1.9–5.1 to account for a larger adverse environmental impact of aviation on atmospheric composition at higher altitudes (CitationChenoweth, 2009; CitationGössling et al., 2007). If it is taken into account, the contribution of air travel to the global anthropogenic GHG emissions may be as high as 6.8% (CitationGössling & Peeters, 2007) with the most pessimistic estimates suggesting the share of aviation is equal up to 9% (European Federation for Transport and Environment, 2006). 3. In contrast to the "direct" environmental impacts associated with vehicle operation, the "indirect" environmental impacts of transport are often associated with vehicle infrastructure processes which include vehicle manufacturing, maintenance and final disposal (CitationSpielmann & Scholz, 2005). "Indirect" environmental requirements of transport also stem from fuel production, transportation and distribution, a so-called "wells-to-wheels" approach (CitationChapman, 2007), and road infrastructure construction, maintenance and disposal (CitationFrischknecht et al., 2007; CitationLenzen, 1999). 4. "Tourism-characteristic" industries include accommodation and catering, transport, equipment hiring and cultural and recreational services (CitationBecken & Patterson, 2006). 5. Holistic or comprehensive environmental assessment is defined in the context of this work as a rigorous analysis of a single impact, for example, global warming, comprising its 'direct' (i.e. operational energy consumption and associated carbon footprint) and "indirect" (i.e. "embodied" energies and carbon) contributions to the total environmental impact of a product or service under review, within its lifecycle. Comprehensive environmental impact assessment does not imply analysis of all environmental impacts (for instance, acidification, ozone depletion, and eutrophication); in contrast, it concentrates on a single environmental impact category but strives to evaluate it as "fully" as possible, as the primary focus of this work is on tourism impacts on climate change. The importance of other environmental and non-environmental impacts associated with tourism is acknowledged; however, they are beyond the scope of this paper. 6. "Original" LCA is based on the methodological framework as recommended by the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) (Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry [SETAC], 2004).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Filimonau et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: