Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Survey analysis reveals varied quality practices across histopathology laboratories in India, indicating a need for improved regulation.
Dear Editor, In India, the healthcare sector is a blend of organised and unorganised providers, a large number of whom operate under an atmosphere lacking rigid census, robust regulation and guidelines. According to the website information on the National Medical Commission (NMC), there are 818 approved medical colleges in the country, of which 433 provide post-graduate teaching in pathology. Two hundred and twenty of these are from the private sector.[1] The existence of a large number of diagnostic laboratories with competence levels spanning the entire spectrum is a known fact, given the lack of proper metrics and robust regulations to harness these under one structure. Accreditation, being a voluntary exercise, is a path chosen by a committed few. Histopathology as a discipline faces challenges that are unique in that the tissue is irreplaceable. The exact number of laboratories providing histopathology services is not known. Hence, the question of whether quality histopathology service is uniformly delivered remains unanswered. According to the information provided on the website of the National Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL), 397 laboratories amongst the total of 2262 accredited medical testing laboratories provide accredited histopathology services.[2] It is worth noting that only 5 states in the country have over 30 laboratories that offer accredited histopathology services. An attempt was made to collect information from a cross-section of laboratories across India that offer histopathology diagnostic services and analyse the information to obtain information about the prevailing quality practices. A set of objective questions was circulated to various laboratories across the country by way of WhatsApp groups, emails and through the websites of professional bodies. This was a completely voluntary exercise, and responses were received through Google Forms for analysis. Responses received were exported to excel, and duplicate responses were excluded. Of the total of 150 invites sent out, 128 responses were received. 101 (79%) were institution-based laboratories, and the remaining 21% were stand-alone. Seventy-six per cent of these laboratories were accredited for histopathology services. The break-up of monthly sample load for histopathology was < 500 specimens in 41%, 500–1500 in 38%, and 21% of laboratoriess had a monthly load exceeding 1500. The majority of laboratories (92%) faced issues related to the adequacy of clinical information on the test request forms. Logically, stand-alone laboratories faced this issue more often Sub-optimally fixed tissue, tissue squeezed into inappropriately sized and shaped containers and tissue in inappropriate fixatives were issues faced by all the laboratories that participated in this survey, though to varying extents. It was noteworthy that even institution-based laboratories faced this problem, albeit in a small percentage of cases. Various measures were taken by the laboratories to ensure that tissues come properly fixed. These ranged from providing the fixatives and containers at one end of the spectrum to rejecting the sample at the other extreme Gross examination and sampling of tissue were performed exclusively by pathologists in 91% laboratories. The remaining laboratories allowed trained senior histotechnicians to handle grossing of small biopsies that required no further manipulation. All laboratories followed published guidelines to ensure adequate sampling, although about three-quarters of them modified the protocol to suit their requirements. All of them indicated their commitment not to compromise report quality through inadequate sampling. Only 6% of the laboratories indicated that they process tissues manually. Carousel-type processors were used more commonly among those who automated the tissue processing. Plastic cassettes were used for processing by 72% laboratories, although only a fifth of them used cassette auto-labellers. About 86% laboratories adopted a pre-defined protocol for changing chemicals used to process tissue. The rest changed the chemicals only when they noticed inadequacies in processing. About 80% laboratories utilised paraffin embedding stations to prepare tissue blocks, and the majority used the plastic cassettes as a base. About 70% laboratories used automated microtomes (50% semi-automated and 20% fully automated). Glass slides were identified using barcodes by only 33% laboratories. Only 6% of the total used auto slide labellers. The labels carried multiple patient identifiers in 17%. The majority (69%) provided only the lab ID on the label. About 50% laboratories utilised autostainers. IHC staining was not available in about a quarter of laboratories. Only 16% of the laboratories used whole slide imaging to varying degrees Quality control practices for monitoring the quality of staining were applied to the daily workflow by all the laboratories. About 90% laboratories defined and monitored quality indicators. EQA participation was confirmed by 83% laboratories. Only 8% of laboratories had a single reporting pathologist Only 18% of laboratories issued microphotographs along with the histopathology report All the laboratories had developed methods to handle chemical waste A 96% of laboratories preserved histopathology specimens for periods beyond 2 weeks after the release of the report. Diagnostic laboratories operate under a diverse work environment in India. The lacunae in medical and diagnostic services in medical schools of the country have been well highlighted by Ahuja et al.[3] ICMR has developed and released broad guidelines for good clinical laboratory practice.[4] The Indian Academy of Cytologists has published guidelines for the collection, preparation, interpretation and reporting of serous fluid samples.[5] To the author’s knowledge, there are no national guidelines related to histopathology tissue processing and reporting released by professional associations of Pathology. Organisations like NMC and NABL have published some guidelines, often drawing on international standards and expert consensus. The author is well aware that the sample size of this survey barely scrapes the tip. Nevertheless, certain patterns emerge, leading to the following observations. Some quality practices exist in various forms in all the laboratories, regardless of their size Accredited laboratories have a more structured quality management system that ensures more extensive and methodical application of quality practices to all aspects of the workflow processes in histopathology. To achieve uniform and optimal quality practices across the country is a task of gigantic proportions. One can make a beginning by addressing multiple issues in a bottom-up manner – first by educating the baselevel clinics and hospitals on the need to handle tissue biopsies in a proper manner and working upwards to equip our institutions not only to scale up their diagnostic facilities but also to review how effectively training on quality control and accreditation is incorporated and imparted in the curricula. A collective effort from laboratory personnel backed by the professional groups may yield better results. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jayaram N. Iyengar (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: