Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Monograph analyzes cliental fosterage in Roman-Parthian relations, suggesting a complex diplomatic history.
At the beginning of Augustus’s reign, the Arsacids, Parthia’s ruling dynasty, sent members of their family to live with the emperor in Rome. To the Romans, it seemed that their great rival in the East, who had destroyed the legions of Crassus and frustrated the ambitions of Antony, had recognized Rome’s prominence by sending hostages. Jake Nabel’s new monograph disputes this Roman-centered view, arguing that Parthians practiced “cliental fosterage,” where nobles often fostered the children of their kings and peers. Thus, although Romans viewed fostering a child of Arsacids as a relationship of control, Parthians construed the exchange as an act of service that created familial bonds. This “pragmatic misunderstanding” was encouraged by both the Romans and the Parthians because it made them both appear to be the stronger partner.Nabel devotes much of his attention to the Parthian perspective, despite the scant existence of sources from Parthia. Consequently, he turns to comparative Near Eastern sources that range from Bronze Age societies to the Abbasid Caliphate and the Kingdom of Armenia, where Arsacids ruled until 428 CE. He grounds much of his analysis on the theory of constructivism, arguing that the basic relationships between actors in a system are defined by shared beliefs and practices (as opposed to neorealism which posits that actors exist in anarchy), and the “middle ground” work of Richard White.In his first chapter, Nabel explains Near Eastern norms for fosterage, describing it as one of many ways to strengthen connections between dynastic families, similar to the way marriage was used to define dynastic relationships. Because Romans avoided foreign marriage, cliental fosterage became the dominant method for the Arsacids to create dynastic bonds with the Julio-Claudians.Nabel discusses the specific Parthian motives for sending fosters to the Roman court in the next chapter. Nabel reintroduces the concept of pragmatic misunderstanding with a quotation from Richard White: communities use “creative, and often expedient, misunderstandings” when negotiating their relationship.1 He asserts that Parthians chose to ignore how the Arsacids of Rome weakened their standing because the relationship allowed them to advance important motives, including exiling rivals, protecting members of their family from courtly intrigues, protecting the dynasty by sending family members away in case of disasters, and forging diplomatic relationships with the Julio-Claudians.After establishing Parthian reasons for sending fosters to Rome, Nabel describes the lives of the fosters in chapter 3 by analyzing examples from the works of Roman authors. Here he disputes the argument that the Arsacids were purely hostages. While they were treated as oddities by being conspicuously displayed at public events, they were also treated with respect by using their titles and their proximity to the emperor. Where chapter 1 focused on West Asian forms of fosterage, here he gives an analysis of the fosterage language used in Latin and Greek as a point of comparison.On multiple occasions, Parthian nobles visited Rome to recruit an Arsacid to lead a coup. Nable analyzes the negotiations between the emperors and these Parthians in detail, situating them within the dynastic goals outlined in chapter 2, concluding that the Julio-Claudians were acting as one member in the Parthian noble network, in contrast to the Roman viewpoint that they were opportunistic aggressors. This chapter includes a thorough investigation of Tacitus, whose account Nabel sees as “a reflection of pragmatic understanding” (p. 142). While Tacitus presents these as conspiracies, they also fit common negotiations used in Sassanian and Armenian sources, which are presented as important ways the nobility ensures just rule.Chapter 5 highlights Josephus’s and Tacitus’s accounts of the Arsacids of Rome after they returned to Parthia. Nabel contends that these sources are better understood as reflections of Roman imperialism than accurate commentary on how the Arsacids of Rome were received at home, but may still hold some truth. The conclusion discusses why the long-lived Arsacids did not maintain a regular fosterage relationship with Rome after the reign of Nero, claiming that Parthians realized that the Roman emperors could not be treated as members of a dynasty, thus family relationships were not an effective way to influence diplomacy.Nabel does an admirable job of meeting scholars of the Near East and scholars of Rome in the middle. Scholars of Persia may have questions about the significance of Roman events Nabel highlights or require more background on Roman politics and diplomacy under the Julio-Claudians. Romanists will need to familiarize themselves with Parthian names that are more familiar in Greek (Phraates/Farhad for example). Nabel also does not include the historical background of the relationship between Rome and Portugal before Augustus, so the importance of this diplomatic approach may seem unclear. While the political situation in Rome is not fully contextualized, Nable helpfully introduces his most significant primary sources such as Tacitus, Josephus, and Movses Khorenats’i.A fundamental aspect of Nabel’s argument is that Romans and Parthians misunderstand each other’s relationship with the Arsacids of Rome. Thus, when a Roman author describes Parthians, they must not understand the nuances Nabel must elucidate to better center the Parthians in these exchanges. As Nabel says, Roman sources about the Arsacids “are best read with ambivalence” (p. 185). Therefore, his arguments that most rely on Roman sources (in chapters 4 and 5) are tenuous.Arsacids of Rome is a thought-provoking book that will make a strong complement to scholars focusing on Roman relationships with the East, diplomacy in the ancient world, and comparative history. Nabel shows the importance of Parthia as an agent in Mediterranean history by focusing on the contrasts between Rome and Parthia, illustrating the deeply-rooted divergences between the Mediterranean and the Near East. The book can stand as a diplomacy-focused companion to Eckstein’s Mediterranean Anarchy, arguing against the claim that states exist in anarchy, or as added depth to Goldsworthy’s Rome and Persia. The book will be challenging for readers who are not familiar with Julio-Claudian Rome or Parthia, but should be approachable for advanced undergraduate students or enthusiasts of Roman history.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brendan McCarthy (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: