Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Retrospective evaluation shows high conformance to germline testing guidance in Veterans Health Administration providers, suggesting effective implementation.
e13571 Background: Mainstream germline testing, where oncology providers obtain consent and order testing directly, facilitates timely access to genetic testing for treatment decisions. The Veterans Health Administration promoted mainstreaming of a 62-gene multi-cancer germline testing panel for certain cancer diagnoses: breast, high-grade or metastatic prostate, ovarian/fallopian tube/primary peritoneal/serous uterine, pancreatic/ampullary adenocarcinoma, medullary thyroid, pheochromocytoma/paraganglioma, colorectal cancer diagnosed before age 50, and mesothelioma. We retrospectively evaluated conformance to guidance for adoption of mainstream testing. Methods: We analyzed all germline genetic tests ordered across VA facilities from February 2023 through December 2025. Test orders were categorized as conforming oncology (mainstream-eligible cancer diagnosis), non-conforming oncology (other cancer diagnosis), or non-oncology tests. For orders placed by oncology providers, clinical appropriateness was determined by ICD-10 code alignment with specified mainstream-eligible cancer types. Conformance to guidance was defined as ordering the 62-gene panel for patients with one of the specified mainstream-eligible cancer diagnoses. Primary outcome was rate of conformance to guidance in our mainstream testing model. Results: Among 13,339 genetic tests ordered by 204 providers across 143 facilities, 3,306 (24.7%) used mainstream testing and 10,033 (75.3%) used traditional genetics. Of mainstream orders, 3,130 (94.7%) were guidance conforming and placed by 109 providers, 161 (4.9%) were non-conforming oncology tests placed by 34 providers, and 15 (0.5%) were non-oncology tests placed by 10 providers. The most common conforming tests were in prostate (55.9%), breast (14.1%) and pancreatic cancers (6.6%), while the most common non-conforming tests with a documented indication were ordered in patients with family history of malignancy (12.1%), lung cancer (9.7%) and melanoma (4.8%). Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate that high fidelity to germline cancer genetic testing guidance by oncology providers is achievable under the mainstream model with 94.7% of testing conforming to guidance. This is critical to our understanding of the effectiveness of mainstreaming and the ability to replicate and scale-up mainstreaming in different health care settings.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stoddard et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: