Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
For over a decade consumption has attracted a growing amount of anthropological interest, and the research on this topic has generated valuable insights. However, this research has ignored issues central to much social science, issues that come under the general heading of political economy. We argue that the anthropological literature on consumption is commonly synchronic and psycho-cultural, that it tends to see cultural variations within society as uni-dimensional, and that it tends to ignore or simplify inequalities and conflict. We sketch a broader view of consumption that avoids these shortcomings, a view that draws particularly on Weber's model of class and status and situates consumption in the reproduction of households. In 1986 a telling article appeared in a telling place. The article was Mort's 'The Texas Chain Store Massacre'. The place was the New Socialist. We take Mort's article to be telling for what it symbolizes regarding the study of consumption. In that journal of new socialism, Mort argued that the academic and everyday worlds had moved beyond the kinds of concerns associated with conventional marxist and socialist analysis, especially concerns about the political economy of production. Workers appeared more interested in consuming than in producing; academics were following that change in orientation; socialist writers would be wise to adjust their analytic focus accordingly. A decade later, Miller (1995) signalled the conclusion of the change that Mort had heralded. The study of consumption seemed likely, he wrote, to transform the entire discipline of anthropology. Miller argued that the global spread of the mass consumption of mass commodities means that people increasingly define themselves, their culture and their world by means of these commodities, rather than by means of older frames such as kinship and ethnicity, which are themselves increasingly defined through consumption. We began with Mort's article because it symbolizes poignantly a profound change in scholarly conceptions of people's relationships with commodities. That change is our concern in this article. The shift away from a concern with production and distribution, the under-cutting of the 'productionist bias' (Campbell 1987: 7) in social science, was accompanied by a shift away from a concern with political economy and the material conditions and inequalities of social life, marked by anthropological topics such as world systems, colonization and articulation.1 Put in other words, we have witnessed not only a change in subject matter, but also a change in the sorts of issues that we address through that subject matter.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carrier et al. (1997) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: