Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this article, I critically discuss the question of utopian intentionality via an attention to the politics of childhood. Principally, this article posits a juxtaposition between grand, fully‐intending, adult hopes for children and more modest, concrete kinds of hoping enacted by young people themselves (especially teenagers). I first outline how childhood and utopia have rarely been interrogated together by academics. Then, focusing upon utopian figurations of hope, I argue that popular ways of treating children in contemporary Anglo‐European cultures rely on oft‐unacknowledged, yet simplistic, utopian ideals. Although often noble in intent, these hopeful ideals expose a number of problems, challenges and omissions in their formulations of childhood, which I discuss in some depth. As a contrast, in the second half of the article, I draw on some empirical research where young people talked about hope in a number of different ways. I connect a discussion of intentionality and spatiality with the ways in which children think and talk about "what is good" for themselves. I demonstrate how — perhaps surprisingly, but certainly contingently — a series of disjointed kinds of hope/hoping, with blurry kinds of intent, emerged from this unlikely context. I conclude by stressing that the very possibility of these connections might unsettle our ethical and affective (pre)conceptions of hope, and by theorising a "scrambled" utopian temporality, imbued with the contingencies of simply "going on" in everyday lives. Acknowledgements The author would like to thank Gavin Brown, Lisa Garforth, John Horton and Jenny Pickerill for their comments on earlier versions of this article. Notes 1. From my background as a social scientist working with young people, I define children and young people as those aged between 0 and 25 years old. Many journals — such as Children's Geographies — adopt this age range in their definitions of young people. Like many working in this field, I take "childhood" as shorthand for a range of strikingly unsubtle popular/policy discourses surrounding the full range of subject positions entailed by those people who are 25 or under. This descriptor encompasses the group of young people discussed later in the paper who although, at 12–18 years old, are teenagers, are still legally and popularly considered "children" in the UK. 2. Similarly, although without explicit reference to "childhood", childlike moments of "free play", creativity and awe are somewhat unproblematically — and somewhat nostalgically — deployed by diverse (post‐)marxist, subversive utopians such as Situationist International and in unsettling utopias associated with ruin or disruption (Pinder Citation2005; Kraftl Citation2007). Whilst most concerned with the relationship between work and leisure in capitalist societies, their valorisation of "free" play contains sometimes unquestioned assumptions that mirror broader nostalgias for childhood/childish experiences. Thanks to Gavin Brown for reminding me of this point. 4. Source: http://www.ohchr.org/english/law/pdf/crc.pdf (accessed 20 February 2008). 5. Source: UK Department for Education and Skills (now Department for Children, Schools and Families) at http://www.dfes.gov.uk/ISA/everychild/greenPaper.cfm accessed 19/12/2007. 6. Source: http://www.hope-for-children.org/ (accessed 21 February 2008). 7. Source: http://www.chifoundation.org/Charitable-organization.htm (accessed 21 February 2008). 3. Other examples include: the UK government's unashamedly utopian "Building Schools for the Future" Programme (DfES Citation2004), and media debate surrounding it; UK‐based "Hope 2008", a Christian programme aiming to transform the everyday experiences and future lives of young people living in relatively deprived urban communities; quite simply (and this simplicity is significant), the sheer number of children's charities that include the word "hope" in their name or mission statements. And so on. 8. Owing to the nature and context of the focus groups, young people were not asked to provide any background information and thus a more precise indication of their ages are cannot be provided here. 9. The project was bound by University ethical codes. Hence, all research was anonymous and confidential (names used here are pseudonyms). For further methodological details about the project, for which there is no space here, please contact the author.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peter Kraftl (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: