Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Discourses of authenticity are symptomatic of an era of destabilized communication hierarchies, participatory media, and reality television programming. Women's magazines are an apt site to examine articulations of authenticity given the genre's traditional emphases on aspirational consumption and "making up" the external self. This study explores constructions of authenticity in the advertising and editorial content of two top-ranked publications, Glamour and Cosmopolitan. Drawing on a qualitative textual analysis of these magazines, the author conceptualizes three overlapping tropes of authenticity: (a) promoting natural, organic products; (b) the celebration of ordinary-looking women; and (c) the encouragement of inner-directed self-discovery. These striations of real products, real external beauty, and real internal beauty, respectively, allow authenticity to seep throughout the texts without fundamentally disrupting their traditional commercial function. Acknowledgments The author would like to thank Jefferson Pooley and two anonymous reviewers for providing insightful feedback and productive suggestions on an earlier version of this document. Notes 1According to the 2011 Audit Bureau of Circulation statement Cosmopolitan's total paid circulation is 3,032,211 and Glamour's total paid circulation is 3,040,013. These magazines are published by Hearst Magazines and Condé Nast Publications, respectively. 2Based on circulation figures from the MRI (2011) published on Cosmopolitan. 3I sampled three issues of each magazine per year beginning in October 2006 and ending with December 2010. The particular issues varied each year to reflect seasonal changes and were based on the availability of issues. In a limited number of instances when a particular issue could not be tracked down, I relied on the one immediately preceding/following it. 4Textual instances were coded as "authentic" if they contained one of these specific referents (authenticity, originality, genuineness, nonconformity, realness, individuality, self-expression, and being true to ones' self) or some variant of these words or phrases (e.g., "be yourself," the joy of "being me," "show the world who you are," "wearing your personality," "embracing your flaws"). Messages denouncing "fake" practices (tanning salons, plastic surgery, excessive cosmetics) were also coded. Visual images were coded as "authentic" if they appeared to depart from the standard magazine/advertising physical aesthetic (e.g., plus-size women, petite women) or from the mass production or commodification process (e.g., natural, organic products, recycled or homemade goods). Images were also coded if they signaled nonconformity (e.g., someone standing out from the crowd in a noteworthy way) or turning away from social norms (see Trilling) in a clearly discernible fashion (wearing a T-shirt with a socially controversial message). 5These figures should be read as estimates as some instances were coded in multiple categories. For instance, a message to celebrate the real you by wearing unique style was coded as "real internal beauty" and "real external beauty." Meanwhile, promotions for Glamour and Cosmopolitan user-generated initiatives were advertorials and thus could be included in either the advertising or editorial category. 6As ad critic Sut CitationJhally (2000) reasons, the contemporary advertising system enhances the need for economic production, which will ultimately impel "the coming environmental catastrophe" (n.p.). 7Of the 109 advertisements coded, 48 of them used the terms "natural" or 'nature." 8Although this particular issue was included in the original sample, I opted to discuss it in the concluding section of this article given that reaction/feedback on the image appeared in subsequent issues and online.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brooke Duffy (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: