Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The issue raised in this essay—the abrupt abolition, without consultation, of the census’s mandatory social questionnaire, by a minority government with a strong ideological bent—is primarily a Canadian one. However, in light of news from the UK and debates (of an admittedly different nature) concerning the U.S. census, it casts light on wider issues such as the nature of statistics, their role in constructing a shared social imaginary, and the role that academic fashions may inadvertently play in paving the way for such destructive political decisions. The outline of the story is simple. On 10 July 2010, articles ran in the Financial Times and the Telegraph (Hope, 2010; Pickard, 2010) announcing that the British government is going to abolish the national census. It is considered too expensive and intrusive, and the data are out-of-date before they can be compiled (data more than one year old are considered to be of no use, according to Britain’s Cabinet Office minister). Instead, it is proposed that administrative data and private data (such as credit ratings) can be relied upon to gather a quasi-instantaneous picture of the British people and society. Similarly, in late June 2010 during the G-20 riots, the Canadian Minister for Industry quietly announced that the Canadian census’s long form—the form distributed to 20% of Canadians and from which detailed income, housing, language, employment, occupational, family, and ethnicity information is gathered, all at a fine spatial scale—will be made voluntary (Proudfoot, 2010). The reason given is that an (unspecified) number of Canadians have complained that it intrudes on their privacy—probably while using Facebook and purchasing goods by credit card over the Internet. This should come as a relief to some geographers. Ever since David Harvey (1973) seminally put the first nail into quantitative geography’s coffin, a number of radical, postmodern, cultural, and other geographers have been hammering away, as indeed have social scientists in other fields. Thirty years of academic bludgeoning seem finally to have borne fruit: a generation of innumerate students, some of whom are now politicians,
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richard Shearmur (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: