Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Political applications of the geoweb: citizen redistricting Introduction and background to redistricting in the USA Redistricting and apportionment are two of the most critical and yet least understood political processes that occur in the United States. Important decisions are often carried out behind closed doors, and although they will affect nearly every resident in the United States, citizens traditionally have little role in the decision making. Citizens are also often at a disadvantage in interpreting the plans that are produced and being able to explore and make alternative plans to the one that fi nally emerges from the state capitol. In this commentary I analyze the role that ‘geoweb’ or new spatial media technologies can play in making this opaque political process more transparent. The current round of redistricting is the fi rst to occur following the emergence during the mid-2000s of tools and technologies variously known as the geoweb or volunteered geographic information (VGI). Of particular interest is the question of whether civic engagement in redistricting would offset the relatively low rates of voter participation and citizen engagement, especially in nonPresidential election years (‘Midterms’). Would engagement in redistricting translate into a more active political engagement in general? Or would VGI-enhanced redistricting simply make it easier to carry out electoral manipulation and malapportionment: a fear that has attended redistricting since computer tools were fi rst applied to it in the 1990s (Altman and McDonald, 2010)? [Assuming malapportionment or gerrymandering can be unambiguously identifi ed (see Johnston, 2002).] This latter fear is cited more generally in the Goodchild and Turner conversation (Wilson and Graham, 2013). New tools and technologies, however exciting, are always susceptible to unintended and undesirable uses. But the deployment of a technology always occurs in some context, in this case a sociopolitical one. Until the last fi ve years computer usage in redistricting was expensive and access to data was restricted to small numbers of people working for state legislatures. During the 1990s, for example, states reported spending more than $500 000 on average for software, hardware, and support. All states used computer technology during 2001 redistricting at a fraction of this cost, increased the public availability of data (78.8%) and even accepted public submissions (81%) (Altman et al, 2005). Nevertheless the numbers of people actually participating remained miniscule and were dominated by specialists. Costs also have remained signifi cant, not only for the process itself (the media reported that the state of Georgia will pay $3.8 million for redistricting this year), but also for legal challenges.(1) The insertion of open access VGI into this situation clearly retilts the landscape away from a cadre of experts, and away from a predominantly public consumption of the plans, and toward public participation and production of plans. Furthermore, by investigating alternative plans, citizens can advocate solutions that meet other criteria (eg, making more competitive districts). Finally, evidence is emerging that citizen bloggers are already analyzing proposed plans: for example, to investigate the political landscape for the 2012 presidential election. Haklay (2011) has offered a hierarchy of VGI involvement. ‘Normal’ VGI and citizen science refers to crowdsourcing and data contributions (eg, OpenStreetMap). ‘distributed intelligence’ VGI is where citizens provide interpretations of information (eg, participate in Q&A fora). In ‘participatory science’, citizens actively participate in the problem defi nition and data collection. The highest level of participation is ‘extreme citizen science’ which
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jeremy W. Crampton (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: