Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The effect of adsorption onto aluminum salt adjuvants on the structure and stability of three model protein antigens was studied using fluorescence and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopies, as well as isothermal titration and differential scanning calorimetric techniques. Lysozyme was preferentially adsorbed to aluminum phosphate (Adju-Phos®), whereas ovalbumin and bovine serum albumin were better adsorbed to aluminum hydroxide (Alhydrogel®). A linearized Langmuir adsorption isotherm was used to obtain information regarding the binding interactions between proteins and adjuvants. Binding energetics and stoichiometry data obtained from isothermal titration calorimetry measurements were complex. Based on the spectroscopic and differential scanning calorimetry studies, the structure of all three proteins, when adsorbed to the surface of an aluminum salt, was altered in such a way as to render the proteins less thermally stable. Besides the pharmaceutical significance of this destabilization, we consider the possibility that this phenomenon may facilitate the presentation of antigens and thus contribute to the adjuvant activity of the aluminum salts. The effect of adsorption onto aluminum salt adjuvants on the structure and stability of three model protein antigens was studied using fluorescence and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopies, as well as isothermal titration and differential scanning calorimetric techniques. Lysozyme was preferentially adsorbed to aluminum phosphate (Adju-Phos®), whereas ovalbumin and bovine serum albumin were better adsorbed to aluminum hydroxide (Alhydrogel®). A linearized Langmuir adsorption isotherm was used to obtain information regarding the binding interactions between proteins and adjuvants. Binding energetics and stoichiometry data obtained from isothermal titration calorimetry measurements were complex. Based on the spectroscopic and differential scanning calorimetry studies, the structure of all three proteins, when adsorbed to the surface of an aluminum salt, was altered in such a way as to render the proteins less thermally stable. Besides the pharmaceutical significance of this destabilization, we consider the possibility that this phenomenon may facilitate the presentation of antigens and thus contribute to the adjuvant activity of the aluminum salts. The interaction of proteins with surfaces is a widely recognized phenomenon of both physiological and technological significance. A particularly important example is the binding of protein antigens to aluminum salt adjuvants. Without the use of such adjuvants, proteins are usually only weakly immunogenic. The aluminum salts are currently the only such agents generally approved for use in vaccines for humans (1.Vogel F.R. Powell M.F. Pharm. Biotechnol. 1995; 6: 141-228Crossref PubMed Scopus (160) Google Scholar). Despite this widespread use, their mechanism of action is still poorly understood. Among a variety of nonmutually exclusive proposed mechanisms, roles as depots for antigen induction of inflammatory responses and delivery of antigen into antigenpresenting cells are commonly proposed, with some evidence for each (2.Lindblad E.B. Immunol. Cell Biol. 2004; 82: 497-505Crossref PubMed Scopus (403) Google Scholar, 3.Gupta R.K. Adv. Drug Delivery Rev. 1998; 32: 155-172Crossref PubMed Scopus (504) Google Scholar). The two most common aluminum salts employed as adjuvants are the phosphate and hydroxide forms. The salts themselves have been well characterized with aluminum hydroxide (Alhydrogel®) usually found in a crystalline state (4.Johnston C.T. Wang S.L. Hem S.L. J. Pharm. Sci. 2002; 91: 1702-1706Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (70) Google Scholar, 5.Shirodkar S. Hutchinson R.L. Perry D.L. White J.L. Hem S.L. Pharm. Res. 1990; 7: 1282-1288Crossref PubMed Scopus (145) Google Scholar), whereas aluminum phosphate exists in an amorphous form (5.Shirodkar S. Hutchinson R.L. Perry D.L. White J.L. Hem S.L. Pharm. Res. 1990; 7: 1282-1288Crossref PubMed Scopus (145) Google Scholar, 6.Burrell L.S. Johnston C.T. Schulze D. Klein J. White J.L. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 2000; 19: 275-281Crossref PubMed Scopus (48) Google Scholar). The points of zero charge (analogous to the isoelectric point of a macromolecule) are 4.0–5.5 and ∼11 for the phosphate and hydroxide salts, respectively. In general, proteins seem to better adsorb to the oppositely charged salts through simple electrostatic effects (7.Seeber S.J. White J.L. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 1991; 9: 201-203Crossref PubMed Scopus (130) Google Scholar), although apolar and ion displacement interactions may play a role as well (8.Iyer S. Robinett R.S. HogenEsch H. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 2004; 22: 1475-1479Crossref PubMed Scopus (75) Google Scholar). What happens to the structure and stability of proteins when they are adsorbed onto the surface of the two commonly employed aluminum salts has not been well characterized. When proteins are adsorbed to solid surfaces, highly polar (including charged) interfaces tend to minimally perturb protein structure and stability, although exceptions are known. In contrast, more apolar surfaces often significantly alter the structure and stability of many proteins (9.Steadman B.L. Thompson K.C. Middaugh C.R. Matsuno K. Vrona S. Lawson E.Q. Lewis R.V. Biotechnology and Bioengineering. 1992; 40: 8-15Crossref PubMed Scopus (82) Google Scholar, 10.Matsuno K. Lewis R.V. Middaugh C.R. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 1991; 291: 349-355Crossref PubMed Scopus (14) Google Scholar, 11.Katzenstein G.E. Vrona S.A. Wechsler R.J. Steadman B.L. Lewis R.V. Middaugh C.R. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 1986; 83: 4268-4272Crossref PubMed Scopus (44) Google Scholar, 12.Brandau D.T. Lawson E.Q. Schubert C.F. Day N.K. Matsuno K. Middaugh C.R. Mol. Immunol. 1991; 28: 1019-1026Crossref PubMed Scopus (6) Google Scholar). The effect of the aluminum salts on protein structure and stability is important from several perspectives. For example, to the extent that epitopes are conformational in nature, their retention (or alteration) may be critical for vaccine immunogenicity. The stability of protein antigens is equally important when they are stored for long periods prior to their use. The latter strongly impacts the utility of vaccines for use in the developing world, where shipping under cold conditions can be problematic (13.Brandau D.T. Jones L.S. Wiethoff C.M. Rexroad J. Middaugh C.R. J. Pharm. Sci. 2003; 92: 218-231Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (153) Google Scholar), and in the use of vaccines against potential bioterrorism agents, where storage for long periods in centralized locations may be critical for their effectiveness (14.Fauci A.S. Clin. Infect. Dis. 2001; 32: 675-685Crossref PubMed Scopus (297) Google Scholar). Therefore, in this study we have examined the effect of aluminum salts on the structure and stability of three proteins chosen to serve as models of typical protein antigens. Their interaction with both salts was tested and binding isotherms constructed for the better binding surface. The thermodynamics of this interaction were then characterized by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). Potential changes in structure of the three proteins were probed by front face fluorescence (to examine tertiary structure) and attenuated total reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (to probe potential changes in secondary structure). Their thermal stability was then compared on and off the surface using the same two detection methods. In addition, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was employed for the same purpose. The surprising finding was that the interactions of the proteins with the highly charged aluminum salts generally destabilized the proteins. The practical implications of these results are here discussed, and a potential significance for the mechanism of adjuvant action is briefly considered. Materials—Proteins (lysozyme, ovalbumin, and bovine serum albumin (BSA) 1The abbreviations used are: BSA, bovine serum albumin; FTIR, Fourier transform infrared; DSC, differential scanning calorimetry; MOPS, 4-morpholinepropanesulfonic acid; ITC, isothermal titration calorimetry; DSC, differential scanning calorimetry; ATR, attenuated total reflectance. ), MOPS, and MOPS sodium salt were purchased from Sigma and used without further purification, unless otherwise noted. Aluminum hydroxide adjuvant (Alhydrogel®, 2%) and aluminum phosphate adjuvant (Adju-Phos®) were purchased from Accurate Chemical and Scientific Corporation (Westbury, NY). Dialysis cassettes (10,000 molecular weight cut-off) were obtained from Pierce. Distilled de-ionized water was used to prepare the buffer. Preparation of Protein Stock Solutions—Protein stock solutions were prepared in 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) buffer. Their concentrations were determined using published extinction coefficients and A280 measurements. Binding Isotherms—Protein working solutions in multiple concentrations were prepared at a concentration twice that of the desired final protein concentration. A stock adjuvant solution was prepared by combining the standard aluminum salt suspension with an appropriate volume of 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) buffer, such that the final calculated aluminum concentration was 3.4 mg/ml. The calculation of aluminum concentration was done using data provided by the supplier in the lot specification sheet. Equal volumes of the protein working solution and the adjuvant working solution were combined in 1.5-ml microcentrifuge tubes. Based on preliminary binding studies, Alhydrogel® was used with BSA and ovalbumin solutions, whereas Adju-Phos® was added to lysozyme solutions. The suspensions were mixed gently by end-over-end rotation at 4 °C for 15–30 min. (A preliminary study of the kinetics of adsorption indicated that protein adsorption was complete within this time period.) The samples were then centrifuged at a force of 14,000 × g for 2–5 min. The supernatant was assayed for protein concentration by measuring the absorbance at 280 nm. The amount of protein bound was determined by subtracting the amount of protein remaining in solution from the amount introduced initially. Isothermal were by protein solutions into a the were in using a model isothermal titration protein solutions were into 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) buffer, and the was used in the of the adjuvant solutions. The adjuvant stock suspensions were with to the desired aluminum concentration. For lysozyme into two lysozyme solutions were the concentrations of were and 10 mg/ml. The Adju-Phos® concentrations were and of respectively. The titration of BSA into Alhydrogel® employed BSA and of of at was into of of were at A volume was employed and the for between The adjuvant suspension in the was at a of the thermal prior to titration and titration of the protein buffer. The data were using to the data to appropriate binding of were from all protein titration For BSA and ovalbumin, the of the titration was from all titration of the The of the final of lysozyme into Adju-Phos® was used to the lysozyme data for The data for each was to a model of multiple binding scanning calorimetry (DSC) was used to the thermal of each protein in solution and adsorbed onto an aluminum salt A differential scanning was used for the measurements. protein adsorbed onto the surface of the adjuvant were prepared as for the protein adsorption were using ovalbumin, and BSA in 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) at and respectively. For in the of of Adju-Phos® and 4 of Alhydrogel® were was to the BSA concentration to for of the adsorbed whereas lysozyme and ovalbumin were and solutions were in into a was at 10 with a was to the cells and the cells between were mixed by and the three to that the suspensions were well A of was used to from 10 °C to °C for lysozyme and 10 °C to °C for BSA and and adjuvant samples were examined to the of data were using The for was from the of the proteins in solution prior to further the of the appropriate adjuvant was from the of the adsorbed proteins. Lysozyme were using a For BSA and ovalbumin, both in solution and in the of ovalbumin adsorbed to were determined by the data to a model using two A model provided the for BSA adsorbed to spectroscopy front face was used to probe changes in the tertiary structure of the protein as a of for each protein in as well as adsorbed to an was of the of the adjuvant For this were of protein adsorbed onto the adjuvant were prepared as for binding For all studies, a protein concentration of was For samples the aluminum concentration was mg/ml. adjuvant were to in the for at 4 °C to to of the adjuvant the of the of 280 was and were from to using a with a were at a scanning of Full were obtained °C from 10 to °C with of thermal at each The data were using an was to all The were then determined using secondary structure of the proteins in solution and adsorbed onto the surface of the adjuvants was using Fourier transform infrared an adjuvant were prepared as for protein adsorption The concentrations of ovalbumin, and BSA in 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) employed in solution were and respectively. For lysozyme adsorbed to the protein and aluminum concentrations were and 4 respectively. The concentrations of BSA and ovalbumin adsorbed to Alhydrogel® were and respectively. The amount of protein adsorbed to the adjuvant was determined by measuring A280 of the supernatant The supernatant was then and The remaining was onto a attenuated total reflectance using a with was were using with a of 4 with a with an A thermal was used to the °C from to The samples were for at each In to the samples thermal were for 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) and adjuvant For of proteins in at each were using In the of samples an of the adjuvant at each were from the of protein adsorbed to the The data were then and between and A was to each using on the of the data were into and the of at two was of Protein amount of each protein that can be adsorbed to aluminum salt adjuvants was determined by adsorption isotherms In 10 mm MOPS (pH 7.4) buffer, all proteins adsorbed to the aluminum salt adjuvant on the of the protein and the points of zero charge of the Lysozyme adsorbed to whereas BSA and ovalbumin adsorbed onto was adsorption of lysozyme onto Alhydrogel® ovalbumin and BSA onto Adju-Phos® under the same conditions not The adsorption data were by the adsorption isotherms as (7.Seeber S.J. White J.L. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 1991; 9: 201-203Crossref PubMed Scopus (130) Google Scholar, S. Hem S. S. Vaccine. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). The is a of the of protein of The the of the The and of the was the at of of aluminum and respectively. the was an of of of aluminum and an of The and of the were and respectively. The for the well with published for the same in water (7.Seeber S.J. White J.L. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 1991; 9: 201-203Crossref PubMed Scopus (130) Google Scholar, S. HogenEsch H. Hem S.L. Pharm. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). The coefficients were published (7.Seeber S.J. White J.L. Hem S.L. Vaccine. 1991; 9: 201-203Crossref PubMed Scopus (130) Google Scholar, S. HogenEsch H. Hem S.L. Pharm. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). S. HogenEsch H. Hem S.L. Pharm. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar), have several of for coefficients for the same of protein and Langmuir adsorption isotherm in a The interactions between the proteins and aluminum salts were characterized by The binding stoichiometry were to the calculated from the linearized adsorption The binding were to the coefficients and the three proteins, with the as the and the for energetics obtained from isothermal titration aluminum in a The binding and for each were determined from the data and were used to changes The interaction between BSA and Alhydrogel® was although The was for the binding between ovalbumin and For the both and to the was used to the effect of adsorption on the thermal stability of the proteins. in and were when the proteins were adsorbed onto the adjuvant in to the protein in solution under the same conditions and The of lysozyme was by °C from to when the protein was adsorbed onto the surface of In both was only a and the for ovalbumin in solution and adsorbed to Alhydrogel® were the was significantly altered and and The of both ovalbumin samples were by two at and In the of the the °C was When the protein was adsorbed onto was a from the The stability of BSA was the most by adsorption to an adjuvant and and BSA a at °C When the protein was adsorbed onto were multiple a from to °C calorimetric of the model protein antigens in solution and adsorbed onto aluminum salt adjuvants in a surface fluorescence spectroscopy was used to changes in the tertiary structure of the model protein antigens adsorbed to the aluminum salts. 10 the of the for lysozyme in solution was at on the were When the protein was adsorbed onto the surface of Adju-Phos® at 10 was a in the the was the of the protein in solution to at point the was significantly In contrast, the fluorescence of the adsorbed lysozyme from 10 to at point was a in the of the the data that the tertiary structure of lysozyme is adsorption to results in a in the thermal stability of the changes were less in the changes of the to the of ovalbumin in a apolar when the protein was in solution at When ovalbumin was adsorbed onto the surface of a in the fluorescence at 10 °C (to In the of the the between 10 and seem to that the tertiary structure of ovalbumin is on the surface of the When the fluorescence at and of ovalbumin in the and of the are compared as a of the is The in at °C for the protein in solution with the in the In contrast, was a in fluorescence at °C for the adsorbed surface binding to a thermally in the bound protein not in the protein in BSA in solution an at at 10 °C When BSA was adsorbed onto this was to and at this from the fluorescence of BSA in solution a The of this protein in the was the same for adsorbed BSA at all that the state of BSA in solution may be to the conformational state of the protein adsorbed to of a in the adsorbed protein is in the of fluorescence as well was employed to changes in the secondary structure of the model proteins in solution and adsorbed to aluminum salt adjuvants as a of Potential to the secondary structure of the protein were in the of the For lysozyme in a to at as the was structure to with When adsorbed to Adju-Phos® the of lysozyme was significantly altered compared with the solution The in the of lysozyme in solution to have to an in structure at the of the the a to at for the adsorbed a at the of an to this the was the same at the for lysozyme in A of the of at and as a of a for lysozyme adsorbed to Adju-Phos® between and °C For lysozyme in a more the same was found to be to the use of in as a of The of the of BSA adsorbed to Alhydrogel® was from that of the protein in solution Based on the of the at and BSA to be less when adsorbed to the adjuvant the was the secondary structure of BSA adsorbed to Alhydrogel® changes in the of the protein in solution were only at a at Based on a of the of secondary structure changes of BSA in solution at a of at The results for ovalbumin were to for BSA, with the of the adsorbed protein from that in solution A and the the secondary structure of adsorbed ovalbumin a more with a in and A in secondary structure was not °C for the protein in solution A and The in secondary structure at this an in for BSA, the data for ovalbumin that the protein altered when adsorbed to the to less thermally stable. aluminum salts are the most commonly used adjuvants in happens to the antigens when adsorbed to their surfaces has been characterized. of adsorption to these salts the structure and stability of proteins is to their use as vaccines as well as the mechanism of The adjuvant to each protein preferentially adsorbed in this study was in with the that the protein with the adsorb to the salt the points of zero charge (Adju-Phos®), and the two proteins have a binding for Alhydrogel® lysozyme for that of protein can be adsorbed of of the protein although both adjuvants have a of binding may be more mechanism of A calorimetric binding for each The interaction between BSA and Alhydrogel® was and The a of water and from the surface of the protein and adjuvant with electrostatic apolar interactions (or in the binding adsorption of ovalbumin onto Alhydrogel® was and The for these results is that protein conformational effects are the changes by the electrostatic Lysozyme adsorption onto Adju-Phos® is both and for a variety of to the thermodynamics of the binding that proteins adsorbed to the surface of aluminum salts have significantly thermal compared with the proteins in changes were determined to be in all The extent to the proteins were destabilized on the surface the proteins, with the ovalbumin and the most better the of this destabilization, we used fluorescence and to the changes in tertiary and secondary respectively. that of the structure of the protein was interaction with the surfaces of the salts. The stability of BSA was most by adsorption onto an aluminum salt the for BSA in solution can be to two at are to the of the adsorbed with the combined with the changes in the at that the fluorescence was not to the of a is that BSA onto the adjuvant in such a way that the to the the A is that BSA in of the of the are BSA is a is to D. Biophys. 2001; 91: PubMed Scopus (44) Google Scholar), the of the protein in solution at is with and the data are with a role for apolar The stability of ovalbumin was the by the determined by of the both in solution and were data indicated thermal fluorescence data that adsorption the protein to a conformational at °C data that the not in a in the of the of ovalbumin changes may be the of a conformational of to for an in of the state with the when ovalbumin was adsorbed to the were in the stability of lysozyme in solution and adsorbed to at °C for the protein on the surface and The changes in secondary structure were more for the protein in The of the at in the of lysozyme adsorbed to that lysozyme may be at A study was to the of lysozyme was on the surface of the the protein was at by in The study determined that protein was from the adjuvant at the be on the surface. was by the of a in the of lysozyme in that the adsorbed protein tend to the protein in solution the that when the protein is adsorbed to the aluminum salt in the protein more to The extent of of these three proteins on these highly polar surfaces is surprising (9.Steadman B.L. Thompson K.C. Middaugh C.R. Matsuno K. Vrona S. Lawson E.Q. Lewis R.V. Biotechnology and Bioengineering. 1992; 40: 8-15Crossref PubMed Scopus (82) Google Scholar, 10.Matsuno K. Lewis R.V. Middaugh C.R. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 1991; 291: 349-355Crossref PubMed Scopus (14) Google Scholar, 11.Katzenstein G.E. Vrona S.A. Wechsler R.J. Steadman B.L. Lewis R.V. Middaugh C.R. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 1986; 83: 4268-4272Crossref PubMed Scopus (44) Google Scholar, 12.Brandau D.T. Lawson E.Q. Schubert C.F. Day N.K. Matsuno K. Middaugh C.R. Mol. Immunol. 1991; 28: 1019-1026Crossref PubMed Scopus (6) Google Scholar). possibility is in interaction of the polar surface of the protein with that of the and are possibility is that the surface of the aluminum salts is apolar of charge by are with the thermodynamics and the conformational A possibility is that the changes in the of the adsorbed proteins. to that the of is significantly surface with by surface The latter possibility is under in stability is for the for protein antigens on the surface of aluminum salt adjuvants potential regarding vaccine For example, the that when the protein to the adjuvant the protein more to such as and In addition, the structure may of the antigen on the surface of the as Therefore, critical that the long stability of the antigen be not only in on the surface of the adjuvant as possibility for this phenomenon may have a on the vaccine is that the stability of the proteins in some way to their The mechanism by aluminum salt adjuvants a better is not well three are commonly (2.Lindblad E.B. Immunol. Cell Biol. 2004; 82: 497-505Crossref PubMed Scopus (403) Google Scholar, 3.Gupta R.K. Adv. Drug Delivery Rev. 1998; 32: 155-172Crossref PubMed Scopus (504) Google Scholar). is that the of a at the of the antigen to be the time for the antigen to with cells and A proposed mechanism is to the of the aluminum 10 are more by and cells R.K. Powell M.F. the and Scholar), of the antigen adsorbed to an adjuvant be to antigen in the of antigen The mechanism of action is by a of the through Aluminum salt adjuvants are to a is that this of adjuvants by of the of a have a between protein antigen stability and D. J.L. A. J. Biol. 2004; Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus Google employed and to in a of the was the most and the most this the between stability and A. S. H. S. S. Biotechnol. Biochem. 2003; PubMed Scopus Google that the less of was more the of lysozyme was found to as the stability of the S. J. Biol. Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). The results in all that antigen presentation is to antigen an for the mechanism of by aluminum salt adjuvants is by this The data that protein structure often destabilized adsorption to the surface of aluminum salts. changes in adsorbed proteins may more to by the in antigen
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jones et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: