Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Because, no doubt, they make arresting titles for books, articles and chapters of books, revolutions abound in the pages of economic historical literature: industrial revolutions (not only the familiar British one of 1760–1830,1 but also medieval ones,2 transport revolutions,3 commercial revolutions (of various periods),4 currency revolutions,5 price revolutions,6 demographic revolutions7 and agricultural revolutions. Apart from the British agricultural revolution, others have been claimed for neolithic man,8 the Arab Empire,9 early medieval Europe,10 16th and 17th century Japan11 and 19th century France.12 One might well conclude that the metaphor is so hackneyed and trite that one has not the effrontery to add to the list. One could, of course, use some periphrasis, such as “accelerated pace of economic development” or “quickening of the growth process”,13 but that is an equivocation. What is of significance is whether, irrespective of what they are called, there are discontinuities in economic history. Most of the models or theories of economic development in the past incorporate them. The dialectical leap of historical materialism is an essential feature of the Marxian development model. Although for Marx the crucial rupture was the transition from feudalism to capitalism, it is not at all easy to distinguish this from the industrial revolution - “The handmill gives you society with the feudal lord; the steam mill, society with the industrial capitalist”14 - and Marx has both industrial and agricultural revolutions in Capital. Since the Second World War, among others, we have had A. Gerschenkron (1952), W.W. Rostow (1960), J. Hicks (1969) and D.C. North and R.P. Thomas (1970, 1973), all with mutations of greater or less suddenness.15 E.J. Jones (1981), writing in it less sanguine decade and interested in “the very long term” and the comparative method, eschews them.16 Discontinuities - whether revolutions, take-offs, spurts, transitions of quantity into quality, disturbances of equilibrium or parameter shifts - have enjoyed long and distinguished support - not least from J.A. Schumpeter's dictum: a new equilibrium “cannot be reached from the old one by infinitesimal steps” (“Add successively as many mail coaches as you please, you will never get a railway thereby”).17
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peter Wickins (1989) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: