Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Scholarship posits that the state is the most powerful actor in “race-making” via its institutionalization of racial categories, especially through national censuses. Yet whether census ethnoracial categories correspond to experientially existing social groups crafted through everyday boundary making is an empirical question. When census categories misalign with micro-level boundaries, inferences drawn from census data may seriously misrepresent intergroup relations. Using unique, multidimensional data on self-classified Hispanics in the United States, the author estimates the degree and correlates of (mis)alignment between Hispanics’ racial self-classifications on a closed-ended, census-style race question and their racial self-identification on an open-ended question. The author finds substantial misalignment between racial self-classification and self-identification, with self-rated skin tone and reflected appraisal particularly important for white (mis)alignment and immigrant generation status strongly associated with the use of hyphenated American identifications. The author concludes that although the state exhibits “race-making” power, reliance on census race categories alone misrepresents Hispanics’ ethnoracial boundary making practices, distorting inferences about the larger U.S. racial structure. Including a Hispanic option on the census race question improves overlap between state and everyday racial categories, but a Hispanic racial self-identification is by no means a universal convention.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kyle Waldman (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: