Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Physical keyboards provide feedback and tactile landmarks that are not present on on-screen keyboards (OSKs). Similarly, physical keyboards provide faster typing speed than OSKs. The present study was designed to address the lack of research into the direct application of different types of feedback and tactile landmarks to on-screen typing with the intent of improving tablet OSK performance. Fourteen participants performed typing tasks using 6 tablet OSK variants: no feedback (the benchmark), audio feedback, visual feedback, haptic feedback, key-shaped tactile landmarks, and inverse tactile landmarks with ridges over the key gaps. Typing performance was not statistically different across the conditions, except for the key-shaped landmarks, which performed worse. This was largely due to the overlay affecting the sensitivity of the keys. The conclusion is that, without additional changes, feedback and tactile landmarks alone do not offer the opportunity to improve the performance of OSKs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dan Odell (2015) studied this question.