Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Rhetoric, theory, and high expectations often guide government action. These political paradigms may conflict with experience. Unfortunately, seeing is not believing. Believing is seeing (Kuhn 1996). Only after con-trary data accumulates and we are forced to reconcile repeated inconsisten-cies are we able to reconsider our political positions and actions. Medicaid managed care programs — the states ’ delivery system of choice — are at the point of forcing us to question received wisdom and firm beliefs. Relying on anecdote and a compelling theory, state Medicaid programs placed 63 percent of Medicaid clients into managed care settings. Faith, however, rarely requires validation. For years, states have operated as if managed care always improved quality, expanded access, and decreased costs. Recent national studies indicate that this is not the case. Nonethe-less, the pretense was tolerable because the rate-setting methodology ostensibly guaranteed that capitated systems would cost less than fee for service and when tax revenues dropped, states could structure managed care to operate within their budgets. In 2003, all of this changed. The federal government required states to set capitation rates that were “actuarially sound. ” Actuaries were for-mally brought into the process, and the American Academy of Actuar-ies developed guidelines. If states were passive entities, actuarially sound rates would have health maintenance organizations (HMOs) become for Medicaid what they have already become for Medicare: the high-priced alternative to fee for service (Berenson 2004).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bruce Spitz (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: