Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Can invention be taught? The pursuit of open-ended commercially focused projects provides opportunities for students to use design and problem solving skills, techniques and tools in a multi-disciplinary team setting. Through this process, students gain the skills, knowledge, confidence and commitment to test their inventive and entrepreneurial skills in the world. This paper provides an overview and profile of two courses developed under a program which provides support for the development of new approaches to engaging students with innovation by providing opportunities for the creation of new products and ventures as part of the educational experience. The National Collegiate Inventors and Innovators Alliance (NCIIA) is an independent interdisciplinary educational program supported by The Lemelson Foundation to foster and promote the teaching of invention, innovation, and entrepreneurship by facilitating and supporting collaborative learning structures at colleges and universities nationwide. A major focus of the NCIIA has been engineering education. The two undergraduate engineering programs described here illustrate the diversity of paradigms that can successfully be used to introduce students to independent innovation. The first, is the Illinois Institute of Technology’s (IIT) “Invention Center” where engineering projects are carried out in the studio environment typical of a Fine Arts class. Students are coached, rather than lectured, on everything that needs to be done to come up with a successful idea, make a prototype, and develop the legal and business aspects of it. The second, the University of Virginia’s Invention and Design course uses a classroom apprenticeship which is created through the use of active learning modules where students are confronted with open-ended problems. In both programs, ideas must be patentable and lead to a working prototype before a semester’s end. In addition, students must deliver a patent description and a business plan, and make a formal presentation before judges from industry. These courses provide an effective approach to meeting ABET Criterion 3 outcome requirements by integrating technical and non technical aspects of applied innovation in an organic way to encourage creativity, self reliance and the emergence of inventive competence. NCIIA grants and resources have supported the development of these courses and the continuation of the most promising of the student projects emerging from them towards commercialization. I. Introduction The National Collegiate Inventors and Innovators Alliance (NCIIA) is a unique interdisciplinary educational program. The NCIIA aspires to nurture a new generation of innovators by helping colleges and universities to prepare undergraduate and graduate students to be inventors and entrepreneurs. The NCIIA and its grant fund were created with funding from The Lemelson Foundation, a private non-profit philanthropy, to support educational initiatives in innovation. The Alliance provides support in the form of grants to faculty and students, services and information for members, and meetings, workshops and other resources designed to assist in the development of new programs focusing on commercially directed innovation. A young and growing program, the NCIIA has close to 100 member institutions. Since its inception in the fall of 1995, it has provided over one and a half million dollars in grants to support 115 classes, programs and student projects at over 70 colleges and universities throughout the country. Approximately one thousand students were involved with E-Team classes and projects during the 1997-98 academic year. The program had its origins in the passionate belief of its benefactors that the health and prosperity of the American economy results in large part from the creativity and ingenuity of American inventors and the unique legal and economic structures that protect and encourage the development and commercial exploitation of their ideas. The primary mechanism in this effort is the E-Team (the "E" stands for excellence and entrepreneurship). An E-Team is a group of students, faculty and mentoring professionals who together pursue the development of an idea, product or invention, or solve an open ended problem in a way that is likely to result in the licensing of new products or technologies or the startup of entrepreneurial ventures. The E-Team serves as an interdisciplinary bridge crossing over barriers between traditional disciplines (such as engineering, business and liberal arts) and between the business and academic communities. It is intended to serve as a flexible, open model and a source of new ideas rather than a doctrine. The pursuit of solutions to the problem creates a “need” for technical knowledge that informs and enriches the students’ learning experience in other courses while providing the broader intellectual development resulting from working in a collaborative group environment 1 . E-Teams were pioneered at Hampshire College an innovative private liberal arts college in western Massachusetts as part of the Lemelson Program in Invention, Innovation and Creativity. Students participated in courses in which teams of students formed to develop solutions to open-ended real world problems by creating solutions with commercial applications. These E-Teams were given the opportunity to apply for grants to support the development of innovative ideas. The project was highly successful in engaging students in the process of collaborative innovation and teaching about creativity and entrepreneurship. Participation in an E-Team was often a watershed experience in a student's academic career and has led to the development of products and businesses in a variety of areas. The success of this program led to the creation of the NCIIA in November 1995 as a national alliance to promote and support E-Teams in higher education. In the first three years of its operation, E-Teams have been created at institutions ranging from large universities to small elite colleges. NCIIA grants provide support to classes where E Teams form in a variety of disciplines including engineering, computer science, business and psychology. Student led teams may also form outside of classes. E-Teams of graduate or undergraduate students can apply for grants of up to $20,000 to pursue the development of their ideas by building prototypes, pursuing patents, writing business plans and doing market research. Brief (less than five page) proposals are accepted from faculty and students at member schools biannually in December and May. Proposals are competitively reviewed by committees of faculty, entrepreneurs and corporate R&D professionals. Grantees are usually funded within 60 days of submission. Allowable expenses include equipment, supplies, travel, technical services, limited faculty stipends and expenses directly related to creating an E-Team program. II. Learning Engineering as Art at the Illinois Institute of Technology (IIT) Engineering education is sometimes described as an assembly process 2 . Educational programs have a perfectly structured series of steps (semesters, course sequences with well-polished syllabi) whose mission is to build the students’ knowledge, piece by piece, in a repeatable manner. A student’s knowledge is being built the way an automobile is built. After all the pieces are put in place by the basic courses, the capstone courses are supposed to make all the connections between them before the product —the new engineer— is delivered to the market. Their knowledge runs quite well for a while with frequent tune-ups (continuing education). Engineers produced in this way, like cars, tend to be inflexible, and become obsolete with time after which they are replaced by newer “models”. When viewing engineering as an art, however, a different paradigm of engineering education emerges. Instead of “assembling” new engineers in a production line, where productivity (maximum knowledge in a minimum amount of time and effort) is the goal, new engineers can rather be “grown” in an organic way. This growth process becomes part of the individual and leads to a long term flexibility and resilience. Art instructors recognize the need to practice the techniques taught in the courses at the same time as they are being learned. Art students take studio courses from the very beginning of their programs. In these courses, the students work on assignments under the watchful eye of the instructor. A master-apprentice relationship is established, which allows the transmission of a type of knowledge that would be difficult to transmit in a standard course 3 . The sense of whether a certain composition “works” is developed with time, by carefully exposing the students to situations that challenge them to use their developing aesthetic sense. In the same way, engineering students can learn what combinations of physical elements, practical and commercial considerations are conducive to a satisfactory result, so that their designs “work” in a very real sense. The engineering studio course "Invention and Innovation" was created as part of the new requirement for IIT undergraduates to have at least six semester credit hours of "inter-professional projects”. These projects are intended to expand the views of the students beyond their academic major. Our "Invention and Innovation" classes combine technical aspects (a working prototype must be built) with law (a patent must be written), business (through a business plan) and social aspects. The program has run continuously for three years under funding from the Fund for the Improvement of Post-Secondary Education and the NCIIA. . Class
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Castro et al. (2024) studied this question.