Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewed by: Diasporic Media beyond the Diaspora: Korean Media in Vancouver and Los Angeles by Sherry Yu David C. Oh Yu, Sherry. Diasporic Media beyond the Diaspora: Korean Media in Vancouver and Los Angeles. Vancouver: U of British Columbia P, 2018. Pp. 248. $75.00 hardcover, $29.95 paperback, $29.95 ebook. Sherry Yu’s book Diasporic Media beyond the Diaspora: Korean Media in Vancouver and Los Angeles advances two purposes: a diasporic understanding of ethnic media, and diasporic media as an intercultural media system. Combining a cultural production approach with content analysis, Yu produces an engaged comparative analysis of Korean ‘diasporic media’ in Vancouver and Los Angeles. Through the analysis of telecommunications policy differences, national policies on multiculturalism, market size, and immigration histories, Yu’s discussion of these case studies reveals how structural differences matter in the shape of Korean diasporic media in the two cities and the implications for these media to contribute to an intercultural media system that is, as Yu argues, marked by availability and accessibility. Including the Introduction, the book is structured into seven chapters. The Introduction sets forward the primary argument of the book, which is that diasporic media are not simply “media for the Other” (6; emphasis in original). Instead, Yu argues that diasporic media are constitutive elements in an intercultural media system that contribute to society beyond the diaspora. Furthering this argument, Chapter One sets the theoretical framework, claiming that intercultural media must be both available and accessible for “broader society” in order to deepen understanding and to enrich dominant culture (21). The chapter also argues that diasporic media is preferable as a conceptualization to ethnic media because of its attention to transnationalism, its emphasis on the liminal character of diasporas, and its implicit inclusion of multiple forms of media content. In Chapters Two through Four, the book carefully examines the policy and economic structures that shape diasporic media as businesses and as sites of media practice. Chapter Two examines the policy differences in Canada and the United States, focusing primarily on telecommunications policy, Canada’s official multicultural policy, and the US’s lack of formal policy. Chapter Three addresses the availability and accessibility of Korean diasporic media in Vancouver, while Chapter Four examines Los Angeles. Each of the chapters is marked by thorough, descriptive detail. In the final two chapters, Yu shifts toward comparative analysis and policy prescriptions. Chapter Five summarizes the preceding description of diasporic media in Vancouver and Los Angeles, comparing the two cities’ Korean-language media and engaging in new directions in her discussion, including implications of the “Korean Wave,” the surge of transnationally distributed Korean mediated texts. In the book’s final chapter, Yu points toward policy prescriptions that would better support diasporic media and in turn create a more progressive intercultural media system. [End Page 185] Though some of her suggestions are politically unlikely, it is important to have these arguments enter into public discourse to structurally and culturally value the role of diasporic media. Diasporic Media beyond the Diaspora makes important contributions to the field of ethnic media/diasporic media/minority media research. Most importantly, it conceptualizes what most scholars refer to as “ethnic media” in a generative new formulation. As Yu points out, it is increasingly necessary to consider transnational flows of ideas, news, media, capital, and people when understanding ethnic and racial difference, including in diasporic media. In addition, her ambitious attempt to demonstrate that Korean-language diasporic media is “media for all” provides an original framework for approaching future work on diasporic media. It is a timely and important intervention. The book’s importance is furthered by focusing attention on production structures, including micro-level newsroom work practices and macro-level policies such as immigration, telecommunication, multiculturalism. In an area of research that is dominated by studies of text and, to a lesser extent, audience reception and surveys, her historically rooted ethnographic analyses of two cities’ Korean-language media are exceptional. The thick description Yu provides is a strength of the book that can inform other media ethnographies, including those that are not centered on diasporic media. Her attention to two different sites in which Korean-language media operate is...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David C. Oh (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: