Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Environmental justice (EJ) scholarship and activism have advanced procedural and distributive justice as integral tenets of public policy design and implementation. New attention is being directed toward underemphasized tenets of recognitional and restorative justice. In this article, we introduce a new open-access, living database and interactive mapping tool—the Coastal California EJ Conflicts Database—which facilitates comparative analyses of actor networks involved in perpetuating and resisting environmental injustices, the mobilization strategies they deploy, and outcomes of 87 EJ conflicts along the California Coast. Methods and Results: The database was built following an engaged, mixed-methods approach involving key informant interviews to inform database design, followed by content analysis of media coverage and key policy documents on EJ conflicts. Descriptive analysis of the database cases reveals that energy and water conflicts are the most common drivers of environmental injustice along coastal California. Leveraging social network analysis, we identified and mapped over 300 unique EJ, extractive industry, and government actors involved across all conflicts, with most EJ actors involved in multiple conflicts, while most extractive industry actors are involved in only a single conflict. Furthermore, we identified a suite of resistance and extractive strategies, which we categorized into four types: operational, legal, discursive, and political. Conclusions: Our descriptive assessment of EJ conflicts in this new database illuminates patterns of similarity in how conflicts emerge, evolve, and mimic tactics across different resources and geographies. We aspire for an open-access dataset and interactive map, alongside the descriptive analysis presented here, to inform more effective EJ mobilization and policy campaigns that move beyond only procedural and distributive justice outcomes, and toward recognitional and restorative justice.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rudnick et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: