Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Social identity theory states that a person’s sense of who they are is based largely on their group membership(s). We categorize ourselves, identify with groups, and compare our groups with others, in the hopes that our self-esteem is maintained or boosted from this comparison. A prerequisite of scientific research, even regarding social identity, is that researchers need to be confident that the empirical facts really are factual; that is, that the sample statistics reported accurately estimate corresponding population parameters; this is known as sampling precision, or how precisely our sample corresponds to our population. By employing the recently invented a priori procedure, the present research assesses the sampling precision with which published experimental and correlational social identity research statistics, across three time periods, estimate corresponding population parameters. We hypothesized 1: The precision of research in the social identity area should be hopefully below the 0.10 level or at least the 0.20 level for true experimental designs and 2: Precision in the social identity area should be improving, with recent social identity research enjoying a precision advantage over less recent social identity research. A sample of 75 academic papers, across 46 different journals was collected for analysis. For experimental studies, the mean precision level was 0.51 and the median precision level was 0.50 (n = 39). For correlational studies, the mean precision level was 0.24 and the median precision level was 0.20 (n = 55). The main findings are pessimistic, but with the glimmer of light that precision is improving.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wilson et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: