Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Noise is an inherent component of many work environments, including health care settings. Noise, as defined by Merriam Webster, is “any sound that is undesired or interferes with one's hearing of something.”1(p840) In addition to the sounds generated by health care equipment, whenever clinicians come together they generate noise while performing clinical activities and communicating with one another, with their patients, and with their patients' family members. Some sounds in the clinical environment are helpful, such as the communication of essential patient information or the sound of an alarm alerting a nurse to a patient's declining oxygen saturation. Sounds also can become annoying and distracting, as when a device sounds an alarm too frequently because of its design or sensitivity. The intensity of sound is measured in decibels (dB). Sound at the threshold of hearing is measured at 0 dB, while sound that causes pain measures 130 dB or more.2 The Environmental Protection Agency has recommended that the average hospital noise level should not exceed 45 dB during the daytime and 35 dB at night.2 Peak, abrupt sound levels in one hospital study were measured at 113 dB, slightly louder than a jackhammer.2 Several studies have investigated the negative effects of noise, showing that excess noise in a health care setting can be unsafe both for patients and clinicians.3, 4 Even though acceptable noise levels have been recommended for hospitals, no data have been published to date reporting compliance of health care organizations with these standards. In the course of a normal day, health care clinicians will be confronted by different types of noise at various levels of pitch, duration, tone, and volume. Sounds of patient monitoring equipment as well as communication among staff members are essential to the provision of health care. Other necessary sounds common to health care settings include clinical alarms, overhead pages, and the call bell system, as well as the noise generated by heating, cooling, and air-filtration systems. Additionally, telephones and pagers are essential tools that help streamline important communications, although at times these same devices can interrupt meetings, conversations, patient evaluations, and surgical procedures. They also can disrupt patients' sleep or contribute to the misunderstanding of instructions, which can lead to medical errors. In an inpatient clinical unit, it is impossible to imagine clinicians providing care to 30 or more patients in one department without talking with patients and coworkers. The level of noise generated by multiple conversations is directly related to the number of people in one space—the greater the number of people, the more potential there is for individuals to be talking at the same time. On any given day on a medical-surgical unit, one might find physicians, medical students, residents, nurses, nursing students, assistive and ancillary personnel, family members, visitors, and volunteers. When the number of people in a confined space increases, the noise of conversation naturally becomes louder as people try to speak with greater volume so they can be heard. Some health care workers believe that excessive noise is simply a part of the environmental clutter of the health care setting. A noisy workplace is something they have come to expect. To cope with it, a clinician may learn to ignore or “turn off” his or her awareness of environmental noise. By accepting the noisy environment, however, an individual may find it becomes easier not to take action to control or reduce the level of environmental noise pollution. The environment of the OR presents additional challenges for clinicians as they work amidst the typical noises of the health care setting. For example, a surgeon may prefer loud music in the background when he or she performs a surgical procedure. Music may be beneficial in some settings, but it also may contribute to the overall noise pollution, especially when it is played at a high volume. Additionally, one person's favorite choice of music may be perceived as dissonant, unpleasant, or distracting by another listener. Imagine walking into an elegant restaurant and having extremely loud music blaring from the overhead speakers. This probably would have a negative effect on the expected ambiance of the fine restaurant and result in patrons choosing to leave. In the work environment, however, employees may be subjected to music they consider to be unpleasant or too loud. If an employee complains about it, he or she may be ostracized or told to endure it because music is just part of their work environment. Loud noises and music in the OR also can contribute to communication problems when a clinician cannot clearly hear another person speaking. When the person speaking is wearing a mask, the words may be muffled further, making understanding even more difficult. Loud music added to the noise from drills, anesthesia machines, sequential compression devices, and various other pieces of equipment commonly found in the OR may create an environment in which it is extremely difficult to work. Excessive levels of noise of any type can affect patient safety. Loud noises or music can cause a clinician to not hear the correct name of a medication or the dose to be administered. In a noisy environment, the physician may ask for “hepsan” and the nurse may hear “heparin,” or the surgeon may say “50,000 units” and the anesthesia care provider may hear “15,000 units.” Any of these situations could occur when noises clutter the environment, threatening the safety of patients. A surgeon asks the anesthesiologist to administer a unit of blood because there is excessive bleeding at the operative site. The surgeon then asks the anesthesiologist to order a spare unit. Because of the several conversations that are taking place and the level of music playing in the OR, the anesthesiologist does not hear this second instruction and, consequently, does not order the blood from the blood bank. Fifteen minutes later, the surgeon accidentally cuts a vessel and instructs the anesthesiologist to run the blood “wide open” and to get the second unit of blood administered as soon as possible. “What blood?” the anesthesiologist responds. The surgeon screams, “The unit of blood I told you to hang 15 minutes ago.” Alarm notification for physiologic monitoring: could you benefit from a new strategy? Health Devices. 2007;36(1):5-21. Busch-Vishniac IJ, West JE, Barnhill C, Hunter T, Orellana D, Chivukula R. Noise levels in Johns Hopkins Hospital. J Acoust Soc Am. 2005;118(6):3629-3645. Joseph A, Ulrich R. Sound Control for Improved Outcomes in Healthcare Settings. Concord, CA: The Center for Health Design; 2007. Kracht JM, Busch-Vishniac IJ, West JE. Noise in the operating rooms of Johns Hopkins Hospital. J Acoust Soc Am. 2007;121(5)(Pt 1):2673-2680. Mazer SE. Increase patient safety by creating a quieter hospital environment. Biomed Instrum Technol. 2006; 40(2)145-146. Schell LM. Effects of noise contribute to physicians' challenges. South Med J. 2007;100(3):241. Seifert PC, Hickman DS. Enhancing patient safety in a healing environment. Top Adv Pract Nurse eJournal. 2005;5(1). http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/499690. Accessed June 15, 2007. affect a person's hearing, increase the level of stress the person experiences, and decrease his or her job satisfaction. Effective management of noise in the clinical environment requires a team effort. First, health care personnel need to agree that excessive noise creates a risk for staff members and patients. If staff members minimize or deny this risk, the facility's safety officer should be prepared to provide convincing scientific evidence supporting the associated risks. The safety officer also can assist in measuring the noise levels in a particular space, providing empirical data to support a noise-reduction initiative. Staff members also need to identify the various sources of noise to determine whether and how these noises can be reduced. Health care facilities have implemented various initiatives to address noise in the workplace. Some hospitals have established “quiet hours” in which staff members deliberately reduce the level of noise. For example, the coronary care unit at the University of Maryland Medical Center, Baltimore, has designated a quiet hour in the afternoon. During this hour, the lights are dimmed, the telemetry alarm volume is lowered, and automatic doors are disengaged. There also are no overhead pages or deliveries, and non-emergency procedures are not conducted.5 In some facilities, surgeons are required to leave their pagers with someone outside of the OR during a surgical procedure. This eliminates the question of who will respond to a page when the surgeon is working in the sterile field. A department may choose to disallow certain types of music or agree on a specific volume setting that helps provide background noise without interfering with safe and effective communication. In addition to these measures, each clinician has a personal responsibility to manage how much noise he or she generates in patient care areas, especially discussing topics that are not related to patient care. For example, nurses should attempt to conduct casual conversations in a break room instead of in patient care areas. Health care professionals also need to consider their personal vocal levels. Most clinicians are aware of which staff members are loud and which staff members are quiet. Which type are you? Do you make your presence known by your loud voice, or are you the quiet one who can enter a room without being noticed? Clinicians should identify which sounds are annoying or noxious within a clinical environment and investigate how these sounds can be reduced in number or frequency. Most likely, some noises can be eliminated altogether. For example, clinical alarms are designed to provide important warnings, but it is appropriate to evaluate new equipment carefully before purchase and to investigate whether a device has a high false-alarm rate. Additional consideration should be given to the selection and use of communication equipment. When these devices have an option to be set on vibrate alert, it is possible to eliminate unnecessary noise even further. By staying alert to the sources of noise and striving to reduce the level of noise in the clinical environment, practitioners can work as a team to create a safer environment both for patients and staff members. Nurses do not need to accept the premise that noise is just something to be endured. It is necessary and appropriate to take action to reduce the hazards associated with noise in the workplace.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Suzanne C. Beyea (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: