Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mechanical engineering capstone design students benefit from interaction with practicing engineers. This is widely recognized, and many programs require students to work on projects that originate with local industry. This approach has the appeal of "real-world" engineering, and the benefit of external project evaluation. However, it can be difficult to reconcile industry-sponsored projects with established capstone criteria regarding scope, objectives, and required elements. Such projects may be too large or too small, and they may encompass only a few aspects of mechanical engineering design. At its worst, different objectives on the part of faculty and industry representatives lead to confusion, resentment, and frustration for students.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mark Archibald (2020) studied this question.