Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper explores the currency of what I term the “Holocaust sublime” in North America. In contrast to, for instance, Hannah Arendt’s historically grounded perspective, popular understandings of the Holocaust have gravitated toward spiritualized and ahistorical interpretations. This trend persists despite the emergence of Michael Rothberg’s theory of “multidirectional memory,” which in many ways perpetuates such spiritualization. Scholars have attributed this persistence to various factors, including the influence of Zionist ideology, American exceptionalism, and media portrayals that frame the Holocaust as a unique, incomprehensible event. This article argues that underpinning these dynamics is what, borrowing from Immanuel Kant, I call the Holocaust sublime: a visceral experience that evokes feelings of social cohesion, heroism, and morality. Drawing on survivor literature, archival documents from the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, memoirs, ethnographies, and interviews with visitors to and trustees of sites of Holocaust memory, this paper explores why such spiritual construals were naturalized, laying special emphasis on fostering diverse social, spiritual, and political projects within Jewish communities, from Zionism to North American acculturation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yasmine Eve Lucas (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: