Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Review
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This review outlines the clinical characterization of demoralization according to the Diagnostic Criteria for Psychosomatic Research (DCPR).
In the late 1960s, Schmale and Engel developed the clinical profile of the “giving-up complex” [1]. Skillful interviewing of patients disclosed a psychological state characterized by unpleasant, distressing feelings expressed in terms such as “it is too much,” “it is no use,” “I cannot take it anymore,” ascribed by the patient to failures or deficiencies in one’s environment (helplessness) and/or to one’s own personal failures or inadequacies for which nothing can be done (hopelessness) [1]. When helplessness occurs, the individual maintains the capacity to react, yet feels being left out and lacks adequate support [1, 2]. In case of hopelessness, the individual feels he/she alone is responsible for the situation, together with the perception that it will last forever [1, 2]. The “giving-up complex”may be identified by additional characteristics: perception of diminished competence and control in one’s own functioning; impairments in relationships with significant others; external environment and/or one’s own performance do not fulfill the subjects’ expectations given by previous experiences; loss of the sense of continuity between past and future, with diminished hope and confidence in projecting oneself into the future; proneness to revive previous unsuccessful or frustrating experiences [1, 2]. Schmale and Engel hoped that their phenomenological description could be refined with operational criteria and the development of specific instruments for their identification [1]. The subsequent development of clinimetrics [3, 4] made this clinical translation possible. In 1995, the Diagnostic Criteria for Psychosomatic Research (DCPR), that were developed according to clinimetric principles, encompassed demoralization as one of the psychosomatic syndromes [5]. The term “demoralization” was preferred to “giving-up” for its immediacy and the fact that the criteria also referred to Frank’s conceptualization [6] and in particular to subjective incompetence as its clinical hallmark [7]. The DCPR criteria identified a feeling state characterized by the patient’s consciousness of having failed to meet his/her own expectations (or those of others) or being unable to cope with some pressing problems. The patient experiences prolonged and generalized (at least 1month duration) feelings of helplessness or hopelessness or giving-up [5]. The clinimetric formulation of DCPR demoralization was found to be consistent with Schmale and Engel’s characterization [8]. After two decades of research and clinical use, the possibility of indicating hopelessness (when the individual feels he/she alone is responsible for the situation and there is nothing he/she or anyone else can do to overcome the problem) as a clinical specifier was included in the DCPR [9]. The aim of this paper was to outline the clinical characterization and implications of DCPR demoralization, as it has emerged from a large body of investigations summarized in two systematic reviews [10, 11] and from our extensive clinical experience.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fava et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: