Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The last decade has seen the judiciary’s legitimacy come under increasing scrutiny as and more sensitive and politically charged battles are fought in the courts. These not only placed constitutional adjudicators in awkward situations but raised about how they are chosen. The process of selecting judges, generally, is one of the most powerful and effective means that could be used by the other branches of government to interfere with and influence the judiciary. Are they through procedures that ensure the appointment of persons based on their and professional merit as well as their ability to decide matters , objectively and fairly? Is there any constitutional design that can the appointment of the calibre of independent-minded judges that are needed a time of tremendous change and when the threats to sustaining Africa’s fragile to entrench an ethos of constitutionalism, good governance, protect human and respect for the rule of law is under siege by pro-authoritarian forces as democrats? paper critically examines, compares and contrasts the systems that operate in Anglophone, Francophone and Lusophone African countries. It starts by the importance and significance of the method of appointing adjudicators. It then examines the divergent approaches to the of constitutional adjudicators. From an analysis of the different used, it shows that political involvement, and sometimes interference to politicisation of the judiciary, is a common phenomenon in all jurisdictions the continent with the differences being only in the degree of interference. It, , proposes constitutional entrenchment of a model of constituting the Judicial Commissions or Conseil Sup erieur de la Magistrature that limits the powers the executives, who often also control the legislature. Whilst it is clearly both from the perspectives of the law and that of political legitimacy to politicians from playing any role in the appointment of judges generally and adjudicators in particular, the paper argues that their role should be to ensure that they will not be in a position to manipulate or control judges.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charles Manga Fombad (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: