Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Do Thomists Have Rights? Dominic Legge O.P. In the standard account of the historical development of the idea of natural rights, the watershed innovation is typically said to be the notion that individual persons themselves "possess" rights: not only that we judge something to be "right" by nature, in an objective sense ("objective right" or "objective rights"), but that individual human subjects "have natural rights" that they can maintain over against others ("subjective rights"). Some view this development of the idea of subjective rights in a positive light as the crucial foundation for contemporary doctrines of human rights; others regard it as a corruption of classical theories of justice and the beginning of the decay and decadence of contemporary liberal regimes.1 For centuries, Thomists—those who lay claim to the principles and heritage of St. Thomas Aquinas—have played a prominent role in this history. In the early sixteenth century, Dominican Thomists like Francisco de Vittoria, Domingo de Soto, and Bartolome de las Casas were instrumental in the development of a theory of natural rights that would serve to limit the power of the Spanish crown and of colonial masters over the natives of the new world. In the twentieth century, in the immediate aftermath of World War II, Jacques Maritain mounted a principled campaign as a Thomist for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. And contemporary [End Page 127] interest in Aquinas's approach to law and justice is increasing, as is evident from several recent publications.2 Yet a lively debate has developed in recent decades over the Thomistic pedigree of subjective rights. Were these Thomists in fact faithful to the principles of Thomas Aquinas?3 Is a doctrine of subjective rights found in Aquinas?4 If not, is it an organic development from Thomas's own views? Or can Aquinas's thought be used in a more general way to ground a theory of subjective natural rights? To put it in the terms of Leo Strauss, does Aquinas truly belong in what he terms the classic natural right tradition, or is Aquinas actually a precursor and forerunner of the modern doctrine of natural rights? (In Natural Right and History, Strauss himself seems to regard Aquinas as a liminal figure, still within the classic tradition but sowing the seeds of its demise in post-Enlightenment modernity.5) The participants in the debate over these questions, whether or not they think subjective rights are a positive development, generally take it for granted that the crucial shift is from a focus on duties based on an objective sense of "what is naturally right, or just, or due" to a subjective theory of "natural rights" that I "possess" as an individual person. It is my claim that such questions miss the point and, worse, hide the fact that, in the centuries after Aquinas, some putative Thomists diverged in important ways from Aquinas's own principles. The resulting (so-called) Thomistic theories of natural rights involved a shift in perspective that has [End Page 128] worked much mischief in the domain of natural rights theory. Recovering Aquinas's own view is, I believe, quite important if we are to think aright about a healthy political order. But contemporary commentators have generally failed to recognize that some supposedly Thomistic theories are only Thomistic masquerades. In order to bring this to view, I will first discuss what I consider to be the key principles of Aquinas's own account and how the distinction between objective and subjective rights is a relatively unimportant side issue compared to the critical insight of Aquinas's position: that law and justice, and consequently any theory of natural rights, should always be understood in terms of an overarching order to the good. Then I will speak about how that key dimension was eclipsed, first in the thought of late-medieval thinkers opposed to Aquinas (like William of Ockham), and then in the thought of Francisco Suarez and subsequent Jesuit and Jesuit-influenced Thomists. Finally, I will discuss how the eclipse of this key dimension has widespread and damaging repercussions and will attempt briefly to make the case that, if we wish to have natural rights in a...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dominic Legge (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: