Why the study?
Are there gender differences in the symptom profiles of clinical depression and social functioning among primary care patients?
Are there gender differences in the symptom profiles of clinical depression and social functioning among primary care patients?
Depressive men in primary care exhibit more serious symptoms and poorer social functioning than depressive women, highlighting the need for greater clinical attention to male depression.
May warrant attention to male-specific depressive symptoms in primary care; leaves open prospective validation of gender differences.
BACKGROUND: There are no great differences in the symptom profiles of depression between the genders in observer rating scales, but women self-report more symptoms. OBJECTIVE: To compare gender differences in symptom profiles of clinical depression in primary care with a short self-report depression scale and an observer-rated scale for social functioning. METHODS: A sample of 436 primary care patients aged 18-64 years were screened using the Depression Scale (DEPS) and interviewed using the Present State Examination (PSE). Level of social functioning was also assessed. Sum scores and single items of DEPS were compared between men and women in the groups of both depressive and non-depressive patients,and the interactions between gender and depression were analysed. RESULTS: Depressive men scored poorer on both instruments. Feeling that everything is an effort and feeling worthless were typical for depressive men. Feeling blue was more typical for non-depressive women than for non-depressive men. CONCLUSION: In this sample of primary care patients, there were differences in the symptom profiles of depression between men and women. Depressive men more commonly had serious symptoms than depressive women. Clinically, male depression deserves more attention. The psychosocial profile of public primary care patients in Finland warrants further research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Poutanen et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: