Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The question of whether or not radiation can be indicted as the principal causative factor in the induction of neoplasia following radiation exposure for either diagnostic or therapeutic purposes has been of increasing interest over the past several years (4, 12, 18, 19, 20). The present investigation was initiated in 1956, in the Cincinnati area, which appeared to offer abundant material for evaluation. The first case of x-irradiation for treatment of “enlarged thymus” was reported from Cincinnati by Friedlander in 1907 (8), and both roentgen diagnosis and therapy of thymic enlargement enjoyed considerable local popularity until recently. Observations from this city were published by Lange in 1914 (11). Since the majority of patients in the series to be reported here were from a group of private and municipal hospitals, none of which is particularly noted as a cancer center, the possibility of bias being introduced by selection of a neoplasia-prone population was thought to be minimal. Historical Review At the time of Friedlander's report, there was considerable medical interest in thymic enlargement as a manifestation of status thymicolymphaticus, a so-called constitutional disorder associated with a tendency to respond catastrophically to minor noxious stimuli. A large thymus was commonly described as necropsy in children who died suddenly, apparently as a result of diminished resistance from status thymicolymphaticus. Moreover, concern was voiced over the possibility of suffocation by tracheal compression resulting from the enlarged gland. X-irradiation, then recently available, seemed to provide not only the means to treat the enlarged thymus but also a method for its detection. It is interesting to note, however, that in Friedlander's case the enlargement was detected by palpation in the suprasternal notch and by percussion! Routine diagnostic x-ray examinations were undertaken among children in whom the risks of sudden death or suffocation seemed greatest: the newborn and those undergoing anesthesia, most frequently for tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy. A wide mediastinal shadow was often the indication for the application of therapeutic radiation even in the absence of signs or symptoms of disease. It is clear that unfamiliarity with available standards misled those gauging thymic enlargement on the basis of weight, while the total absence of adequate standards was disregarded by those who used roentgenographic size as an index of abnormality. The anatomic weight standards of Hammar (9) and of Boyd (2) clearly showed that 50 to 90 per cent of normal healthy children have thymus glands weighing more than the “accepted upper limit” of 20 gm. The rapid decrease in cell population and size of lymphoid structures with many types of stressful stimuli was not appreciated; and there was practically no knowledge of the equally rapid recovery of thymic weight after acute illness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Saenger et al. (1960) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: