Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Prologue: California has long been a battleground in the struggle to reform the traditional relationship between patients, payers, and providers. Many of the reform issues—particularly whether government should mandate employers to provide health insurance to their workers—that are now before Congress have been the subject of previous debates in California. In this paper Tom Oliver and Emery Dowell depict these struggles and how they were resolved or left untended. Oliver and Dowell underscore one of the realities about American democracy—that private interests play a critical role in shaping public policy. Oliver, who holds a doctorate in political science from the University of North Carolina, is an assistant professor in the Policy Sciences Graduate Program at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation recently bestowed on Oliver one of its Investigator Awards in Health Policy Research. Dowell is a retired vice-president for governmental affairs of Blue Cross of California. This paper draws upon his experience working among health care interest groups as an honest broker (or, as he put it in a telephone conversation, “a legendary nuisance”) in an effort to craft a compromise solution to California's insurance access problem. Dowell helped to draft and promote the 1989 health insurance reform legislation sponsored by Assembly Speaker Willie Brown, the legislature's most powerful figure, and also consulted with the California Medical Association and the insurance industry. Dowell is a member of the California Managed Risk Medical Insurance Board, which designed the first statewide, government-sponsored, regional health insurance purchasing pool for small groups (see Health Affairs, Spring I 1994, page 350). Abstract: We review the 1992 policy choices in California for expanding health insurance coverage, focusing on the rejection of an employer mandate by legislators and voters. We analyze how interest-group politics, gubernatorial politics, and national politics shaped those choices. Although public opinion and the shift of organized medicine showed considerable support for extending health insurance coverage, the opposition of liberal and conservative groups and a foundering economy prevented a significant change in public policy. The president's health reform plan appears to address many of the unresolved concerns in California, but overcoming resistance to any kind of mandate will require skilled leadership and negotiation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Oliver et al. (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: