Key result
High versus low exposure to the FIFA 11+ program was not associated with differential changes in the structure of select trunk and lower extremity muscles in adolescent female footballers.
Why the study?
Does comprehensive FIFA 11+ delivery alter the structure of select trunk and lower extremity muscles in adolescent female footballers compared to unsupervised delivery?
RCT (n=23)
Cluster-randomized
No
Does comprehensive FIFA 11+ delivery alter the structure of select trunk and lower extremity muscles in adolescent female footballers compared to unsupervised delivery?
Different levels of FIFA 11+ exposure were not associated with differential changes in the structure of the investigated trunk and lower extremity muscles in adolescent female footballers.
High FIFA 11+ exposure does not alter select muscle structures in adolescent female footballers; challenges structural adaptation as a key mechanism.
Background The FIFA 11+ is an injury prevention program found to reduce lower-extremity injury risk; however, the mechanisms behind this protective effect are not well understood. One possible explanation is the program addresses trunk and lower-extremity muscle deficits. Objective To determine the impact of FIFA 11+ exposure on the structure of select muscles in adolescent female footballers. Setting Sport Medicine Clinic. Design Sub-study embedded within a cluster-randomized controlled trail (RCT). Participants 23 female footballers (14–16 years) recruited from three teams that participated in a FIFA11+ implementation strategies RCT. Intervention: Participants were recruited from teams randomly assigned to one of two FIFA 11+ delivery groups; coach with unsupervised website access (control; n=11) or, coach with pre-season FIFA 11+ workshop and on-field physiotherapist supervision (comprehensive; n=12). Main outcome measurements Pre-post season bilateral sonographic measures of: resting Rectus Abdominis (RA), External/Internal Oblique, Transversus Abdominis, Lumbar Multifidus (MF), Gluteus Medius/Minimus (GMd/GMn), and Vastus Mediallis (VM) thickness; VM width and inter-recti distance (IRD); change in abdominal parameters during an Active Straight Leg Raise (ASLR) and gluteals during hip abduction. Mean (95% CI) pre-post season changes in sonographic parameters were calculated and group means compared with paired t-tests (=0.05). Results No differences in 95% CIs existed for pre-post season change in sonographic parameters between participants with low (mean=149±9 exercises/year) and high (mean=314±15 exercises/year) FIFA 11+ exposure. Both groups exhibited significant within-group IRD decreases at rest (low t=8.20, P<.001; high t=5.90, P<.001) and with the ASLR (low t=5.66, P<.001; high t=5.04, P<.001). Further, the lower exposure group demonstrated decreased ASLR percent RA thickness change (t=3.19, P=.01) while the high exposure group exhibited increased resting MF thickness (t=2.26, P=.04). Conclusions Different levels of FIFA 11+ exposure in this investigation were not associated with differential changes in the structure of the muscles investigated. Protective mechanisms underlying the FIFA11+ may be associated with alterations in neuromuscular control resulting in IRD and MF adaptations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Whittaker et al. (2014) conducted an RCT in Healthy adolescent female footballers (n=23). FIFA 11+ comprehensive delivery (high exposure) vs. FIFA 11+ control delivery (low exposure) was evaluated on Pre-post season change in sonographic parameters of select trunk and lower extremity muscles. High versus low exposure to the FIFA 11+ program was not associated with differential changes in the structure of select trunk and lower extremity muscles in adolescent female footballers.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: