Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This exploratory mixed-methods classroom study investigated the use of ChatGPT in International English Language Testing System (IELTS) writing preparation classrooms, focusing on a) the reliability of holistic scoring, b) the actionability of feedback, and c) teacher and student acceptance. Specifically, it compared three model variants (ChatGPT 4, 4o, and 4o mini) to examine whether scoring and feedback performance were stable across commonly accessible versions within the same artificial intelligence (AI) ecosystem. Data were collected from Chinese IELTS teachers, native-English-speaking IELTS teachers, peer student raters, and IELTS essay writers in an advanced-level preparation context. Quantitative analyses examined score reliability and the frequency of actionable feedback across IELTS writing domains, while qualitative analyses of feedback and interviews identified recurring patterns in feedback characteristics and user acceptance. Five themes emerged from interview data: utility and functionality, perceived reliability of scores, actionability of feedback, concerns about over-reliance, and balancing AI with human oversight. Findings suggest that the tested ChatGPT variants generated relatively reliable and actionable feedback for surface-level features (e.g., grammar, spelling, lexical choice), but showed limitations in evaluating context-sensitive and higher-order dimensions (e.g., argument depth and creativity). Participants generally viewed ChatGPT as a useful supplementary tool rather than a replacement for teachers. Practical implications for integrating AI and human feedback in IELTS writing classrooms are discussed, and important limitations related to sample size, proficiency range, single-prompt design, and model version currency are also acknowledged.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhao et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: