Key result
White-noise stimuli generated significantly larger heart rate, skin conductance, and eye blink electromyographic responses compared to pure-tone stimuli (p < 0.001), whereas recording posture had no significant effect.
Why the study?
Does white noise compared to pure tone, and sitting compared to supine posture, affect peripheral physiological responses to loud sounds in healthy subjects?
Does white noise compared to pure tone, and sitting compared to supine posture, affect peripheral physiological responses to loud sounds in healthy subjects?
Effect estimate: generalized eta squared 0.073-0.076
p-value: p=<0.001
White noise stimuli generate larger peripheral physiological responses than pure tones, and supine positioning does not substantively change these responses, suggesting white noise is preferable for fMRI studies of autonomic sensitization.
White noise may elicit stronger autonomic responses than pure tones in research; leaves open optimal stimuli for clinical autonomic testing.
In the "loud-tone" procedure, a series of brief, loud, pure-tone stimuli are presented in a task-free situation. It is an established paradigm for measuring autonomic sensitization in posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Successful use of this procedure during fMRI requires elicitation of brain responses that have sufficient signal-noise ratios when recorded in a supine, rather than sitting, position. We investigated the modulating effects of posture and stimulus spectral composition on peripheral psychophysiological responses to loud sounds. Healthy subjects (N = 24) weekly engaged in a loud-tone-like procedure that presented 500 msec, 95 dB sound pressure level, pure-tone or white-noise stimuli, either while sitting or supine and while peripheral physiological responses were recorded. Heart rate, skin conductance, and eye blink electromyographic responses were larger to white-noise than pure-tone stimuli (p's < 0.001, generalized eta squared 0.073-0.076). Psychophysiological responses to the stimuli were similar in the sitting and supine position (p's ≥ 0.082). Presenting white noise, rather than pure-tone, stimuli may improve the detection sensitivity of the neural concomitants of heightened autonomic responses by generating larger responses. Recording in the supine position appears to have little or no impact on psychophysiological response magnitudes to the auditory stimuli.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Koch et al. (2016) studied Healthy subjects (n=24). White-noise stimuli vs. Pure-tone stimuli was evaluated on Peripheral physiological responses (heart rate, skin conductance, and eye blink electromyographic responses) (generalized eta squared 0.073-0.076, p=<0.001). White-noise stimuli generated significantly larger heart rate, skin conductance, and eye blink electromyographic responses compared to pure-tone stimuli (p < 0.001), whereas recording posture had no significant effect.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: