Key result
Non-consultant general surgeons were 10.4% more likely to decide to perform an emergency laparotomy than consultants, highlighting differences in decision-making by seniority.
Why the study?
Emergency laparotomies carry high morbidity and mortality, with outcomes inextricably linked to the decision-making process of whether or not to operate.
Does surgeon grade influence the decision to perform an emergency laparotomy?
Cross-Sectional (n=116)
Does surgeon grade influence the decision to perform an emergency laparotomy?
Non-consultant general surgeons are significantly more likely to decide to perform an emergency laparotomy compared to consultants, highlighting a difference in decision-making and risk attitudes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant caution in training pathways for emergency decisions; leaves open whether grade-specific thresholds affect outcomes.
INTRODUCTION: More than 30,000 emergency laparotomies take place annually in England and Wales (Symons et al. in Br J Surg 100(10):1318-1325, 2013; Shapter et al. in Anaesthesia 67(5):474-478, 2012). They are associated with high morbidity and an average inpatient 30-day mortality rate of 11%. Inextricably linked to outcomes is the decision-making process of whether or not to operate (NELA Project Team First patient report of the National Emergency Laparotomy Audit. RCoA, London, 2015; Crebbin et al. in Aust N Z J Surg 83(6):422-428, 2013). A mixed-methods study was undertaken to investigate decision-making in the emergency laparotomy and influencing factors. METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were undertaken amongst general surgeons, exploring the decision-making process. Results helped guide design of an online survey, consisting of vignettes and subsequent questions. Respondents were asked to decide whether or not they would perform a laparotomy for each vignette and the results compared to grade, risk attitudes and reflective practice. Responses were analysed for effect of previous positive and negative experiences and for consistency. RESULTS: Interviews revealed multiple important factors when considering whether or not to perform an emergency laparotomy, broadly categorised into patient-related, surgeon-related and external factors. A total of 116 general surgeons completed the survey: 12 SHOs, 79 registrars and 25 consultants. Non-consultants were 10.4% (95% CI ±9.7%) more likely to perform an emergency laparotomy than consultants (p = 0.036) on multivariate analysis. No association was observed between operative practices and risk attitudes (p = 0.22), reflective practice (p = 0.7) or previous positive or negative experiences in univariate (p = 0.67) or multivariate analysis. Surgeons were not proven to be either consistent nor inconsistent in their decision-making. CONCLUSION: The decision to operate or not in an emergency laparotomy directly effects patient outcome. This study demonstrates a difference in decision-making and risk attitudes between consultants and their juniors. To address this, formal teaching of models of decision-making, influencing factors and vignette-based consultant-led discussions should be introduced into surgical training.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hendra et al. (2018) conducted a cross-sectional in Emergency laparotomy decision-making (n=116). Non-consultant grade vs. Consultant grade was evaluated on Decision to perform an emergency laparotomy (10.4% more likely, 95% CI ±9.7%, p=0.036). Non-consultant general surgeons were 10.4% more likely to decide to perform an emergency laparotomy than consultants, highlighting differences in decision-making by seniority.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: