Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Systematic review examines bathing strategies to manage aggression in older adults with dementia, suggesting improved caregiver practices.
Background The management of behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) is a challenging area in the provision of care for older adults with dementia. Among BPSD such as psychosis, depression, agitation, aggression or disinhibition,1 aggression is one of the most frequently observed BPSD. Kverno et al.2 conducted a retrospective chart review of 123 nursing home residents with advanced dementia in USA and the most prevalent symptoms were reported to be aggression or agitation (50.4%), depression (45.5%), and withdrawal/lethargy (43.1%).2 Care-related BPSD also have a high prevalence both in residential care and community settings. Family caregivers in home settings in USA reported that 65% of 183 older adults with dementia exhibited care-related BPSD, occurring weekly or more often in 31%, and daily in 16% of cases. Verbal and physical aggression was found in 50% and 46% of the cases, respectively. 3 In residential aged care settings where severity of dementia is expected to be high, incidence of care-related aggressive behaviours was reported to be up to 86%.4 5 Bathing can be a highly unpleasant occasion for both formal and informal caregivers who provide assistance to older people with dementia. Physical and emotional challenges in assisting bathing have been well-documented. Hoffer et al.6 reported from their cross sectional study of multiple aged care facilities in the USA, a large proportion of residents exhibited aggressive behaviour during bathing. In one facility, over a 4-week period, care staff observed that 41% of residents became physically or verbally aggressive at least one-quarter of the time during bathing, while 16% demonstrated aggressive behaviour at least three-quarters of the time during bathing.6 Similarly, a staff survey of 71 aged care facilities in the USA revealed that 20% of residents were difficult to bathe due to behavioural symptoms such as resistive or aggressive behaviours.7 Commonly reported aggressive behaviours during bathing include kicking, scratching, grabbing, screaming, and cursing at caregivers and others.8 Caregivers can also become soaked as a result of clients pulling on shower hoses, and pounding the bathwater.8 It is evident that assisting bathing can cause emotional distress for caregivers while their physical/occupational safety can be in danger. Some studies have examined the impact of caregivers’ behaviours on the occurrences of aggressive behaviours during daily care including bathing. In a nursing home in the USA, 105 cases of physical assault by residents with Alzheimer’s disease were videotaped to determine immediate antecedents of bathing-related physical assaults against caregivers. It was shown that caregivers’ behaviours 5 seconds prior to an assaultive incident were significantly associated with the assaults by residents. Caregivers’ behaviours that were identified as triggers of aggressive behaviours included inappropriate verbal communication with residents, and invalidation of the resident’s feelings or needs. It was also found that spraying water without a verbal prompt significantly increased the risk of assaultive behaviours.9 Similarly, the benefits of educational programs based on the person-centred-bathing approach for caregivers have been also reported in the USA.10 11 What is significant about these studies is that the findings clearly support the view that aggressive behaviours of older adults with dementia are largely (if not mostly) a response/defence to unpleasant stimuli/experience from the bathing environment and caregivers. Therefore, improved caregivers’ communication and practical skills are highly likely to facilitate positive outcomes for both caregivers and older people with dementia. This accelerates an important change of discourse in hands-on care areas such as bathing that may have once been considered to be “a trivial topic”, towards new practice supported by scientific findings. Aggressive behaviours during bathing may be managed more effectively and appropriately by clinicians following implementation of evidence-based findings. Several systematic reviews have identified evidence to manage BPSD behaviours of older adults with dementia.12 13 However the scope of such reviews tends to be broad and does not specifically address different care activities such as bathing, that requires evidence to guide detailed practical elements of care. A major reason for the limitations of previous systematic review reports in this specific topic is lack of sufficient primary research reports. Hands-on nursing care such as assisting bathing older people with dementia, has probably received little attention from the research community. This may be due to difficulty in applying rigorous scientific rules in investigating or developing an effective method in such a practical area where there are simply too many variables to control. Similarly, despite the current rise of the qualitative research movement in health care fields, this type of practical topic does not appear to have received much attention from the research community, either. This might be due to various reasons such as: researchers’ preferences for “glamorous topics”, lack of recognition for daily hands-on care among clinicians and researchers, and lack of financial and human resources to conduct research. To overcome this obstacle, textual-opinion papers will be considered for inclusion in this review, if a limited number of research reports are identified. There is a large number of textual-opinion papers published in nursing and aged care journals. This type of publication is a window into clinicians’ practical experiences that can be also termed tacit knowledge or what Aristotle called “Practical Wisdom” 14 - a type of knowledge that also reflects unexamined cultures and discourses around the bathing of older adults with dementia. Although such papers are not based on rigorous research methods, it is likely that clinicians and care providers can receive content-specific (bathing older adults with dementia) guidance and insights to improve their everyday practice. Thus, this project aims to examine currently available published and unpublished literature regarding the assisting bathing/showering of older adults with dementia to provide clinicians and caregivers with evidence-based recommendations and guidance to improve both clients’ and clients’ outcomes. Results related to the community setting and the aged care setting will be analysed and presented separately. This is because it is anticipated that the evidence related to community settings is likely to address supportive and educational interventions for family caregivers in home settings while the evidence related to aged care settings is related to trained-formal caregivers in institutional settings. Operational definitions: Dementia: Dementia is a condition in which there is a gradual loss of brain function; it is a decline in cognitive/intellectual functioning The main symptoms are usually loss of memory, confusion, problems with speech and understanding, changes in personality and behaviour and an increased reliance on others for the activities of daily living.15 Aggressive behaviours:16 being verbally abusive or threatening being physically threatening, such as kicking or pinching lashing out violently at people or property overreacting to a situation, or becoming very agitated as a result of what seems to be a very minor setback or criticism. Meaningfulness Extent to which an intervention or activity is experienced by the patient. Meaningfulness is about how an activity or intervention related to the context in which care is given. 17(p.11) Appropriateness Extent to which an intervention or activity fits with or is apt in a situation. Clinical appropriateness is about how an activity or intervention relates to the context in which care is given. 17(p.11) Objective: The objective of this systematic review is to determine the best available evidence regarding assisting bathing/showering of older adults with dementia in aged care facilities and community settings. Review questions: The quantitative component will aim to answer questions of effectiveness: What is the most effective bathing/showering method in reducing agitated or aggressive behaviours in older adults with dementia in aged care facilities and community settings? What are the most effective bathing/showering method and related educational/ supportive interventions in improving confidence and satisfaction level of nurses, care staff or family caregivers in assisting bathing/showering older adults with dementia? The qualitative component will aim to answer questions of meaningfulness, appropriateness and feasibility: What are the bathing/showering experiences of older adults with dementia? What are the experiences of nurses, care staff and family caregivers in assisting bathing/showering older adults with dementia? The textual component will aim to provide supplemental evidence to the quantitative and qualitative components. Participants: Older adults with dementia (assessed using scales such as Mini Mental Scare Examination, Global Deterioration Scale) in aged care and home settings Nurses and formal care staff Family caregivers Type of studies: The quantitative component of the review will consider any randomised controlled trials (RCT); in the absence of RCTs, other research designs such as pseudo-controlled trials and before and after-studies, will be considered for inclusion. The qualitative component of this review will consider studies focused on qualitative data including, but not limited to, designs such as phenomenology, grounded theory, ethnography, action research and feminist research. The textual component will include non-research opinion papers, discussion papers and clinical guidelines will be considered for inclusion. Intervention: phenomena of interest Assisting bathing/showering of older adults with dementia and related educational or supportive interventions for nurses, formal care staff and family caregivers Comparison (quantitative component) Usual care Outcome measures The quantitative component: Frequency and severity of aggressive or agitated behaviours measured by scales such as RAGE (Rating Scale for Aggressive Behaviour in Elderly) Satisfaction rate by residents, family caregivers or nursing/formal care staff Confidence rate of residents, family caregivers or nursing/formal care staff The qualitative component: Subjective accounts of nurses/formal care staff or family caregivers in assisting bathing/showering older adults with dementia Subjective accounts of nurses/formal care staff or family caregivers to have received educational or supportive interventions related to bathing/showering older adults with dementia Subjective accounts of older adults with dementia in receiving assistance in bathing/showering Subjective accounts of older adults with dementia in receiving interventions aiming to improve bathing/showering experiences/outcomes The textual component: Discourses or perceptions related to the provision of assisting bathing/showering for older adults with dementia, that have been derived from clinical experience (tacit knowledge of clinicians). Search strategy: The search strategy aims to find both published and unpublished studies. A three-step search strategy will be utilised in each component of this review. An initial limited search of MEDLINE and CINAHL will be undertaken followed by analysis of the text words contained in the title and abstract, and of the index terms used to describe article. A second search using all identified keywords and index terms will then be undertaken across all included databases. Thirdly the reference list of all identified reports and articles will be searched for additional studies. The review will only considered studies published in English due to a limitation of linguistic support. The search will be also limited to studies published before September 2010. The databases to be searched will include: MEDLINE CINAHL EMBASE Scopus ScienceDirect Sociological Abstracts PsycINFO Grey literature will be searched using: Conference Proceedings Dissertation International TRIP Mednar Google Scholar (included in Mednar) and Google Website of professional bodies in the aged care field Australia Aged and Community Services in Australia Aged Care Association Australia Council on the Ageing Carers Australia Aged Care Standards and Accreditation Agency National Ageing Research Institute UK Department of Health NHS Your Health Your Choices English Community Care Association Help the Aged National Care Association National Care Forum USA American Health Care Association American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging National Long Term Care Ombudsman Resource Center Nursing Homes magazine Resource Centers for Minority Aging Research (RCMAR) Critical appraisal: Quantitative papers selected for retrieval will be assessed by two independent reviewers for methodological validity prior to inclusion in the review using standardised critical appraisal instruments from the Joanna Briggs Institute Meta-Analysis Assessment and Review Instrument (JBI-MAStARI). (Appendix I) Qualitative papers will be assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute Qualitative Assessment and Review Instrument (JBI-QARI) (Appendix II) and textual papers will be assessed using the Narrative, Opinion and Text Assessment and Review Instrument (JBI-NOTARI). (Appendix III) Evidence-based guidelines will be assessed using AGREE (Appraisal of guidelines and evaluation) (Appendix IV) and other guidelines will be assessed using the JBI-NOTARI.(Appendix III) Any disagreements that arise between the reviewers will be resolved through discussion, or with a third reviewer. Data extraction: Quantitative data will be extracted from papers included in the review using the standardised data extraction tool from JBI-MAStARI. (Appendix V) Qualitative data will be extracted using the standardised data extraction tool from JBI-QARI Appendix VI) and textual papers will be assessed using JBI-NOTARI. (Appendix VII) Data from Guidelines and textual papers will also be extracted using the JBI-NOTARI tool. (Appendix VII) The data extracted will include specific details about the interventions/phenomena of interest, populations, study methods and outcomes of significance to the review question and specific objectives. Data synthesis: The data obtained from aged care settings and community settings will be analysed and presented separately. Quantitative data will, where possible be pooled in statistical meta-analysis using the JBI-MAStARI. All results will be subject to double data entry. Odds ratio (for categorical data) and weighted mean differences (for continuous data) and their 95% confidence intervals will be calculated for analysis. Heterogeneity will be assessed using the standard Chi-square. Where statistical pooling is not possible the findings will be presented in narrative form. Qualitative research findings will, where possible be pooled using the JBI-QARI. This will involve the aggregation or synthesis of findings to generate a set of statements that represent that aggregation, through assembling the findings (Level 3 findings) rates according to their quality, and categorising these findings on the basis of similarity in meaning (Level 2 findings). These categories are then subjected to a meta-aggregation in order to produce a single comprehensive set of aggregated findings (Level I findings) that can be used as a basis for evidence-based practice. Where textual pooling is not possible the findings will be presented in narrative form. Textual papers will, where possible be pooled using the JBI-NOTARI. Parallel to the qualitative synthesis method, pooling of textual papers involves categorisation and meta-aggregation/synthesis to produce a single comprehensive set of aggregated/synthesised findings that can directly guide practice. Where pooling is not possible, the findings will be presented in narrative form. Conflict of interest No conflict of interest is anticipated. Acknowledgement This review will be submitted towards the award of Masters in Clinical Science and as such, a secondary reviewer will be used only for critical appraisal and data extraction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Konno et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: