Key result
Shifting from individual to team-based performance evaluation using tools like social network analysis is necessary to improve perioperative care quality and reduce costs.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This perspective highlights the critical need to shift from individual physician performance metrics to team-based evaluations in perioperative care to improve outcomes and reduce costs.
As the proverb goes, “It takes a village to raise a child.” This sentiment reflects the notion that a team of people within a community are responsible for the task of raising a child, including parents, friends, neighbors, and teachers. The outcome of such a complex process cannot be attributed to one person. The same is true for managing chronic diseases, performing surgical procedures, and assisting patients to achieve and maintain a healthy status. The patient may encounter a primary care physician, specialist, anesthesiologist, surgeon, postoperative surgical intensive care unit (ICU) nurse, caseworker, and pharmacist, each of whom has an influence on the patient’s outcomes. Yet, despite the important contributions of each member of the team, the trend is to increasingly measure and report the effectiveness of a single physician, often the surgeon, without regard to the effectiveness of the team that delivered care for the patient. This Open Mind article seeks to explore teamwork in the perioperative setting, discuss current trends both supporting and inhibiting teamwork, and suggest social network analysis as a potential research tool for examining effective team-based performance. USHERING IN AN ERA OF TEAM-BASED PERFORMANCE To meet the demand to provide quality care, there must be a shift from individual performance to team-based performance. Team performance is of critical importance in achieving quality outcomes. For example, the Joint Commission reported that between 2004 and 2015, the most frequently identified root cause of anesthesia-related sentinel events was poor communication. In addition, for certain surgical errors such as wrong-site surgeries and retained foreign bodies, inadequate leadership was the primary root cause.1 These breakdowns in communication and leadership cannot be attributed to one person but are more indicative of shortcomings among team members. There is empirical support for the importance of teamwork in achieving performance outcomes in the operating room. A study found that more stable surgical team membership was associated with lower risk of errors such as sharps-related percutaneous blood and body fluid exposures.2 Another study found that when teams displayed infrequent team behaviors such as speaking up with concerns or showing mutual respect, patients had higher odds of death or complication than teams that displayed these behaviors frequently.3 However, much remains unknown about how to facilitate true teamwork in the perioperative setting and whether this can be accomplished through training, or whether it occurs more organically. Research evidence varies regarding the effectiveness of teamwork training in improving surgical outcomes. Training has been shown to improve teamwork behaviors,4 but there is mixed research evidence about whether these trainings lead to better outcomes. A recent UK study using interventions to implement systems redesign and lean quality improvement in surgical settings found greater results in improving both technical and nontechnical performance when combined with teamwork training.5 However, a similar study found that although nontechnical skills improved after aviation-style training for surgical teams, so did the number of operative glitches.6 In simulated cases, better teamwork and communication were not associated with better clinical performance when using published teamwork survey tools such as the Anesthesiologists’ Nontechnical Skills, Scrub Practitioners List of Intraoperative Nontechnical Skills, Nontechnical Skills for Surgeons, and Observational Teamwork Assessment for Surgery.7 A study found that the perceptions of positive teamwork by team members was associated with lower risk-adjusted morbidity. But interestingly, in the same study, when aspects of team performance were measured using validated scales such as the Safety Attitudes Questionnaire, the observed measures of teamwork were not found to be significantly associated with team performance.8 This apparent contradiction may be explained by the differences in measurement tools for team behavior and actual teamwork and cohesion. These studies suggest that there is something about team performance and its influence on outcomes that is not fully captured by available tools to assess teamwork. Although the members of the team can perceive this unmeasured element, it appears that current measurement tools for understanding and assessing teamwork are falling short. Most hospitals do some form of team-based training, such as the Team Strategies and Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety (TeamSTEPPS) program, which has shown promising initial results.4 However, the aforementioned research findings suggest that some forms of teamwork training may be ineffective, and that team performance may not always be achieved methodically through training alone. This leaves an opening for the idea that important elements of team performance may be more organic, arising from frequent partnership and interaction over time. Surgical teams are often loosely coupled, ad hoc teams that can pose challenges for effective teamwork behaviors.9,10 Therefore, structures that support team effectiveness and stability are of great importance. The perioperative surgical home (PSH) model acknowledges the importance of team performance in patient care and seeks to formalize team coordination into its structure.11 The PSH model requires both coordination among team members and a physician team leader who will serve as an integrator to bring various members into alignment to meet cost, quality, and population health management objectives.12,13 Although this team leader has often historically been the surgeon, others suggest that the anesthesiologist or internal medicine hospitalist is uniquely positioned to take on this role.13,14 Given the importance of this integrating role in achieving better patient care, many questions remain. How will the performance of this integrator be evaluated? What role will this integrator have in advocating for team combinations that deliver the highest quality care? The implications for better team performance in the perioperative setting go beyond the quality of care delivered. There is a vast opportunity for reducing medical expenditures through perioperative care improvement. Estimates for the cost of surgical errors are highly variable, yet significant in their contribution to the problem of escalating health care expenditures within the United States. The Health Care Cost Institute estimated in 2011 that surgical admissions account for 52% of spending for inpatient admissions.15 Malpractice settlements for surgical never events alone totaled $1.3 billion over a 20-year period, not including the costs associated with the additional inpatient and ongoing disability care required for these patients.16 A study evaluating 4 types of surgeries for a national sample of hospitals (between 286 and 824 hospitals depending on surgery type) across a 3-year period found that inefficient and ineffective hospitals generated surgery-related costs in excess of $325 million, which was 8% more than predicted values based on referent hospitals. Approximately 95% of these additional costs were driven by inefficiency, followed by greater adverse outcomes rates (5%).17 The PSH model holds promise for reducing expenditures associated with surgical care. Pilot studies of the model have found that the successful implementation of a PSH may reduce costs by decreasing the length of stay, complication rates, perioperative spending, and readmissions.18–20 However, for this model to work, both internal and external financial incentives must be aligned to reward gains in improvement in care coordination and cost savings.13 ONE STEP FORWARD, ONE STEP BACK New payment models have encouraged the development of team approaches to care management and represent one step forward in terms of recognizing the value of effective team performance and demonstrating a willingness to pay for it. With the passage of the Medicare Access and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) Reauthorization Act (MACRA) in 2015, as a result of a bipartisan effort, Medicare is moving toward physician payment tied to a value-based (VB) reimbursement system.21 Alternative VB payment models, such as bundled payment arrangements, hold the provider organization accountable for the entire episode of care and outcomes that involve multiple members of the team. Rarely is one person on the care team responsible for operating on the wrong limb, for a premature readmission, or for adverse outcomes. These are usually indicative of a deeper issue within the system of care delivery such as gaps in processes, lack of accountability, and reconciliation mechanisms, or a team culture that does not support speaking up or calling a timeout when the patient is in danger. Quality-based payment incentives and penalties encourage and incentivize health systems and administrators to fix lapses in team performance and processes, as well as system-level issues that impede the delivery of high quality care. These incentives may help build the economic and financial case for team-based models such as the PSH, which is necessary for their development and survival.13 However, there are countervailing trends that may mitigate the progress described above. The effects of these payment incentives that recognize the value of team performance in the delivery of care are counteracted by a growing trend to rate and publicize quality metrics for individual physicians. The trend toward individual ratings of physicians may be seen as one step backward in the promotion of team-based care. University of Utah Health Care presented a novel approach when it publicly announced that it would publish unfiltered physician evaluations and comments from patient surveys on its website.22 Press Ganey, 23 a popular patient satisfaction survey administrator, offers an additional service to help hospitals rate individual physicians based on feedback from patients. Consumer Reports is now posting ratings for physicians, including thoracic surgeons.24 Although this may make sense for primary care physicians or certain subspecialties that operate as solo practitioners, it is not applicable for the many physicians who are greatly affected by the efficacy of their team. Although the surgeon is obviously a key driver of the surgical outcomes, a variety of physicians share the responsibility for the final outcomes: pathology, radiology, anesthesiology, and the staff in the surgical ICU. Yet, there are seldom ratings for anesthesiology (aside from pain specialists), or for the many clinical support services that have a tremendous impact on patient outcomes. Because these ratings are only published for certain types of providers and do not capture team performance, they may create misperceptions and misunderstandings. These rating systems are being developed under the auspices of creating transparency to allow informed consumer choice. Consumers are taking advantage of these ratings outlets, with 59% of respondents in a recent survey reporting online ratings as being important when choosing a physician. Of the respondents who had used physician rating sites in the past year, 35% reported selecting a physician based on good ratings, and 37% reported avoiding a physician based on bad ratings.25 Although a patient may have a role in choosing their surgeon or primary care physician, they often are unaware of who their anesthesiologist will be until their preoperative visit or hours before the surgery. The hospitalists and critical care team rounding in the surgical ICU are largely anonymous until the patient interacts with them; minimal choice is involved. However, choosing a surgeon based on ratings without understanding the efficacy of the team with which the surgeon will be operating could be viewed as misleading for patients. IMPLICATIONS FOR RESEARCH Based on the challenges noted previously in measuring teamwork, new tools are needed to better understand how teams are associated with outcomes. One such tool is the use of social network analysis, which allows researchers, clinicians, and administrators to better understand and analyze team performance, and to connect team structures to outcomes such as cost and quality measures. Social network analysis is based on the premise that there are links between a set of actors and that these links can be used to understand and interpret the behavior of the actors.26,27 This analytical tool is informed by social network theory, which suggests that behavior cannot be solely understood by examining individual characteristics because individuals are influenced by the larger social network in which they operate. In the perioperative setting, this suggests that the linkages between physicians, nurses, technicians, and administrators provide key insights into their behaviors, including teamwork and performance. A social network analysis can provide a visualization of which patterns of linkages or team formations are more effective than others. For example, some providers preselect their “team members” based on known results and previous experiences and relationships. Others are forced based on approved payer networks, available operating room slots, and shift work alignment. As narrow networks develop and legislative reform prompts changes in the insurance markets, these historical social networks can become deconstructed with waning effectiveness because of the need to re-establish relationships, working patterns, and referral patterns. Social network analysis has been used in many formats for analyzing the behavior of health care providers within a network. For example, in the perioperative setting, social networks have been used to study surgeon social networks and their role in health disparities,28 communication patterns in the operating room,29,30 surgical team composition,31,32 the integration of ambulatory surgery centers with larger health systems,33 and performance outcomes of surgical team stability.2 Social network analysis has also been used to determine which clinicians are more central to the network, and therefore may be able to influence multiple teams through their interactions with other actors.31 However, more research is needed to better understand how these networks are associated with performance outcomes in the perioperative setting, especially along the varying dimensions of VB reimbursement. CONCLUSIONS In the future, health care leaders should seek to understand the creation, composition, and performance of teams as a framework for analyzing a provider’s effectiveness in delivering care to patients. Although individual accountability is important, the effect of a team on an individual’s performance must also be heavily considered. Additional study for a deeper understanding of the nuances of team effectiveness within the perioperative setting is required. Many questions remain regarding team effectiveness, with important implications for patients, providers, administrators, and society. Who is responsible for choosing these teams? If team dynamics do affect outcomes, should this choice be offered to patients? Or should the physicians be allowed to select their teams because it is their reputations for performance that will be made public and transparent? DISCLOSURES Name: Katherine Meese, MPH. Contribution: This author helped write and revise the manuscript, and with background research. Name: Nancy Borkowski, DBA. Contribution: This author helped with concept, analytical tools, and revise the manuscript. This manuscript was handled by: Maxime Cannesson, MD, PhD.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Meese et al. (2017) conducted an editorial in Perioperative care. Team-based performance was evaluated. Shifting from individual to team-based performance evaluation using tools like social network analysis is necessary to improve perioperative care quality and reduce costs.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: