Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I am happy to step out from behind the curtain and introduce myself to the readers of the Journal of Elder Policy (JEP). I am Kaitlyn Langendoerfer, PhD and have been the Managing Editor alongside Editor-in-Chief, Eva Kahana, PhD (Case Western Reserve University) since the inaugural issue of JEP in the summer of 2020. It has been exciting to see the journal grow and evolve over the years. This is our first published issue after the partnership of Policy Studies Organization with Wiley Publishing Company resulting in a more accessible, user-friendly journal for our authors, reviewers, and readers. The current issue focuses on the important topic of autonomy within the context of aging and later life. Across disciplines, autonomy can be summarized as the ability to make one's own decisions. It is important to note that the concept of autonomy is a “philosophically complex and ethically problematic value, thick with distinctions, polarities, and interpretive variation,”1,p.10 making it particularly worthy of deeper exploration. For example, if an individual can make decisions, but cannot execute the decisions themselves are they autonomous? If an individual appoints someone to make their decisions, are they autonomous? Is someone autonomous if they begin to make decisions that others perceive misalign with the individuals personal values/morals? Despite the interpretive variation of its definition, research has demonstrated that having a greater sense of autonomy as one ages can lead to better mental and physical health outcomes,2-4 higher quality of life,5, 6 and even living longer.7, 8 Given that social scientists focus on social, structural factors, what can we make of the significance of autonomy in later life outcomes? As someone who studies and intentionally tries to combat ageism, I was shocked when my 6 year old son stated that our pet horse, Piglet, may die soon. When I asked him why he thought this he nonchalantly stated that it was “because Piglet has gray hair on his face and that means he's old.” This conversation between my son and I left me thinking about how even at a young age, he's been socialized to associate gray hair with old age and subsequently, decline and death. In her recent book, Breaking the Age Code (2022), Rebecca Levy presents the many ways in which we become socialized into our age beliefs and perceptions of old age. Through our constant exposure to negative stereotypes, particularly in the United States, we learn to dread, or even fear the process of aging. While reflecting on an ageist incident involving her grandmother, Levy realizes that messages related to aging and older adults are everywhere in our society. She states, “the billboards for ‘age-defying’ skin treatments, late-night ads for local plastic surgeons going on about wrinkles as if they were generals describing hostile enemy forces, the infantilizing greetings older people endured in restaurants and movie theaters. Everywhere I looked, in TV shows, in fairy tales, and online, old age was treated as though it meant forgetfulness, weakness, and decline” (p. 4). These negative messages related to age have been shown to be internalized as early as 3 years old.9 My son's perceptions of aging are therefore unsurprising. Our age-segregated society does little to foster inter-generational interactions outside of our family members, which could potentially combat the negative messages about later life that we are constantly exposed to.10 While later life can pose challenges (e.g., health issues, functional impairment, widowhood) due to the cumulative effect of wear and tear over time, older adults tend to be far more proactive and adaptive than society (and sometimes research) gives them credit for. Additionally, being dependent on others or seeking assistance does not necessarily mean that someone lacks the ability to make decisions or state their preferences.11-13 In reality, the current cohorts of adults growing older are more active than ever before. The percentage of older adults still in the labor force is projected to rise over the next 10 years14 and more older adults appear to be functioning better on their own, remaining out of long-term care facilities and assisted living settings15 compared to previous generations. Given these facts about current and future cohorts of older adults, why do we continue to associate aging with decline? Despite ageist messaging, research has repeatedly shown that age itself is not the cause nor the indicator of loss and/or decline.16 My own life experience provided an unfortunate case study of the intersection of age, decline, and autonomy. At 53 years old, my mother, Dr. Kathleen Gillmann, was diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's and died from the disease last year (2023) at the age of 59. Out of the approximately 6.5 million individuals living with Alzheimer's, she was one of the 5% diagnosed before the age of 65.17 As the “early-onset” designation indicates, she was “off-time” and “young” in terms of her age for developing cognitive decline. Her experience is further demonstration that age itself does not cause disease or bodily decline. Upon her diagnosis, I moved home to Pennsylvania from Cleveland, Ohio where I was in graduate school at Case Western Reserve University working on my doctorate in Sociology. Being an only child of a single mother, I took on the role of her main caregiver for the next 7 years. Along with being her caregiver, I also was her power-of-attorney and healthcare proxy. These two designations meant that I legally could make decisions related to her health and allowed me access to her financial accounts. My first task was to let her know that she could no longer drive and assist with her retirement after a 30 year career as a Chiropractor. I was pregnant with my first child at the time and thankfully my mom was happy to begin her new role as “grandma” upon her retirement. As her disease progressed over the years, her verbal communication grew worse and eventually we had to assist with feeding, bathing, and toileting. In the final 9 months of her life, she could no longer walk and was confined to her bed the majority of the time. The exception was when I had the help of our paid caregiver, my aunt (her sister) or my husband to lift her into a wheel chair where she could sit for a short period of time. While immersed in caregiving and the grief that followed, I could not intellectually consider autonomy and its relationship to her experience However, this special issue of JEP has ignited my thoughts about this concept. Did my mom ever completely lack autonomy? Did the physical and cognitive decline that my mom experienced decrease her autonomy gradually over time? Did her autonomy get revoked upon her diagnosis? When I took over as her caregiver? When she could no longer speak? When she was bedbound? It's not surprising that there are many intellectual and legal debates surrounding these very questions. Despite being entitled legally to make healthcare decisions in the early stages of dementia, research indicates that there is a presumption of incapacity beginning right at diagnosis.18-20 I found this to be true for my mom. While I was asked for her power of attorney documents to access her bank and credit card accounts, I was never asked to prove that I was her healthcare proxy during her medical visits. In these settings, once they heard of her diagnosis, they would direct any and all conversation and questions to me. There appears to be a blurred line between having the ability to make decisions (even legally) and the societal perception that you no longer have the capacity to do so once you are labeled with cognitive decline. I would argue, along with others,20-22 that individuals like my mother can and do maintain their autonomy even in the face of severe decline. In my mother's case, she did lack most of her ability to articulate decisions as her she reached the late stages of the disease. Yet, she could still turn her head away at times when I offered food or water, she would sometimes kiss my small children while they laid on her bed with her, and she would reach out her hands occasionally toward me when I left her room, as if asking me to stay. While caring for my mom, I remember being relieved that she had been so proactive in her future care planning. Even though I did not need the legal documents as much as I would have expected, it would have made things infinitely more difficult had my mom not had them in place. Additionally, my mom shared her health and end of life care preferences with me on numerous occasions before her diagnosis. While I wish that my mother never developed Alzheimer's, I am comforted knowing that I was executing the decisions that she had made and wanted. Additionally, I felt relieved knowing that my mom was still capable of making some of her own decisions at the end of her life, even if it was only to turn her head to refuse a drink of water when she wasn't thirsty. My mother's experience encapsulates many of the culturally perceived threats to autonomy in later life and highlights areas where these perceptions can and should be challenged. Additionally, it points out the potential processes that contribute to the maintenance of autonomy even when it's threatened. For instance, my mom was able to preserve her autonomy in certain situations and settings due to her network of social support (myself and others) and her financial resources. Many times older adults may not have adult children or grandchildren, a spouse/partner, or any other support networks in place that can ensure that their preferences and decisions are honored. Additionally, many older adults or their families may not be able to afford the care that they desire. Being middle-class, my mother had a savings account and received decent Social Security and Medicare benefits which aided in our ability to keep my mom in her own home as she coped with the decline. Without having the help of a paid caregiver and eventually hospice, I would not have had time to care for my mom and my three small children (all under 5 years of age at the time). While not knowing her fate, my mom had also planned ahead. She had created a living will when I was born, she eventually assigned me as her proxies, and she shared her healthcare and end of life preferences. Lastly, while her role of being a beloved Chiropractor in our small community was a key part of her identity, taking on the role of “Grandma Kappy” meant so much more to her and made her transition to “retirement” easier. All of these things, arguably maintained her autonomy throughout her short, but special life. Similar to my mom's story, the articles featured in this issue of JEP describe the ways older adults proactively respond to maintain their autonomy despite stressors that they face in later life. Social gerontologist, and JEP's Editor-in-Chief, Dr. Kahana's Comprehensive Preventive Corrective Proactive Model (PCP) (see Kahana et al.),23 provides a useful framework for unpacking our current issue of JEP. This model calls attention to proactive behavioral adaptations such as health promotion, planning ahead, helping others, anticipatory moves, proactive illness management, role substitution, marshaling support, and environmental modifications. These adaptations can be preventive or corrective and are “undertaken by older individuals to actively deal with impending or extant aging-related stressors.”23,p.468 This model also highlights the importance of external (financial and social) and internal (optimism, altruism, coping, future orientation, self-esteem, locus of control) resources. All of these components are conceptualized and have been shown to have an impact quality of life outcomes.24 As we introduce the thought-provoking articles below, you will notice that proactive adaptions and resources are not only important for what has been labeled “successful,” “healthy,” “optimal,” and “positive” aging, but are also vital for adapting to situations that challenge/threaten autonomy throughout the life course. Additionally, while the PCP model provides a framework for discussing the articles in this issue, it does miss one key component that these articles all bring to the forefront—the potential influence of public policy on autonomy. That being said, all of the articles detailed below use qualitative methods to connect seemingly individual experiences in later life to broader social policies. Each provides concrete policy recommendations that can foster autonomy and subsequently impact later life outcomes for older adults and potentially challenge ageist societal beliefs. Additionally, in line with our other issues, the articles are written by interdisciplinary experts and examine autonomy within different global contexts. “Life Wouldn't be as Full without the Shed”: New Directions for Men in Retirement” by gerontologist, Melinda Heinz, PhD, focuses on the understudied topic of men's transition to retirement in Ireland. Retirement has been shown to be a particularly challenging adjustment for men in terms of their identity. This qualitative study examined Men's Sheds in Ireland and how they help men navigate retirement by seeking out ways to preserve autonomy outside of paid work. Men's Sheds are still in their infancy in the United States but are well-known and widespread in Australia, Canada, and the UK. They are defined as spaces where men can make social connections, learn new skills, and have the agency to make decisions about activities at the Shed. Heinz's study included 37 men ranging in age 65−92 years old from 14 Sheds throughout Ireland. Using a thematic approach, her findings reveal that the older men viewed themselves as “doers” and strived for continuity and productivity in their postretirement years. As such, the Sheds, provided a space where older Irish men could develop new friendships, maintain a sense of purpose, and fill a void produced by retirement. Heinz's policy recommendations focus on financially supporting Men's Sheds while also highlighting the potential for employers to offer support for their employees, even if it is just acknowledging the psychological implications of the adjustment to retirement. While retirement can pose a threat to one's autonomy in later life, living on an island that lacks supportive care for older adults poses a different set of challenges. The interdisciplinary team of authors, Elaine Eliopoulos, JD, Chris Gilleard, PhD, and Paul Higgs, PhD, describe how context and environment can shape the aging experience within their article “Contextual Corporeality: Life in the Ninth Decade and Beyond.” Their study features 22 older adults (aged 80−102) who are aging in a unique and understudied context—three islands in the Pacific Northwest of the United States (San Juan Island, Orcas Island, and Lopez Island). This setting is particularly interesting because it has been designated as a medically underserved. Using interviews and photo elicitation, the participants reveal that despite the islands' lack of long-term care facilities, most of the them wanted to stay in their familiar locations (the islands) indefinitely and had concrete plans in place in case they require more care. The sense of reciprocity, close-knit community, and mutual help on the islands was weaved into the stories of the participants. This paper underscores the importance of the community and the common identity of the islanders in their daily experiences with old age. Additionally, this study showcases that “old people” are not a problem to be solved; rather, they are “citizens and members of a shared community.” The authors argue that this approach could influence aging policy to be less focused on chronology and corporeality which currently “emphasize the divisions within later life.” Finally, the article by sociologist Rebecca Marfawtem Amin, PhD, “Later Life Employment: Benefits and Challenges Experienced by Older Immigrants from Sub-Saharan Africa Living in Georgia” examines the integration of older Sub-Saharan African immigrants into American society through employment in the state of Georgia. Research demonstrates that Sub-Saharan African immigrants find it challenging to adapt to their new country of residence due to discriminatory attitudes and perceptions in the host country. However, employment has been shown to benefit older immigrants, particularly in terms of their autonomy. To examine this relationship, Amin interviewed 27 older immigrants aged 55−85, the majority of whom were men, employed, highly educated, and who could speak English. While many of the respondents did report experiences with discrimination, employment within the United States provided them with opportunities to sponsor the schooling of children in their home country, send remittances home, and secure financial stability in later life. It's important to note, that in their home country these older adults would be close to retirement in terms of their age and resources. However, in the United States, they felt they could not retire yet due to their responsibilities at home and lack of accumulated wealth in the United States. In other words, while employment in the United States bolstered autonomy in some ways, it also created threats to autonomy. Policies proposed by Amin focus on ways to speed up foreign credential evaluation and educational interventions to inform immigrants about health and retirement benefits and resources. The current issue of JEP calls attention to the potent ways in which our social and structural environments, cultural scripts, and even life transitions (such as retirement) threaten our autonomy as we age. Despite these threats, the featured articles highlight that there are proactive strategies that individuals can engage in to preserve and maintain their autonomy in later life. These include marshaling support, planning ahead, helping others, role substitution, and environmental modifications.23 In addition to describing proactive responses, the articles also make important policy recommendations that can bolster individual agency and independence in later life. As Eliopious and colleagues pointed out, these social policies not only have the power to influence individual-level outcomes, but also have the potential to shift the cultural scripts that have a direct impact our age beliefs and subsequently our autonomy. The author declares no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kaitlyn Barnes Langendoerfer (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: