Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Evaluates vessel motion impacts on crew performance and operability in coastal navigation, suggesting a tailored approach for small vessels.
It is well known that vessel motions directly influence the crew’s ability to perform onboard tasks. This issue is particularly relevant for certain types of vessels, such as fishing or tug vessels, where the main part of operational tasks are carried out at sea instead of when they are berthed in port. Despite this, none of the existing onboard welfare or operability guides is specifically designed for these kinds of vessels. The best-known references remain related to motion sickness, such as the Motion Sickness Index or the Vomiting Index, which were originally developed for passenger vessels and target discomfort rather than operational performance (O’Hanlon & McCauley, 1974). Other standards, such as ISO 2631, address occupational exposure to whole-body vibrations (International Organization for Standardization, 2008). The only indicator explicitly linking vessel motion to task interruption is the Motion Induced Interruption Index, which was developed for naval applications, therefore does not reflect the operational realities of small and medium-sized vessels (Graham, 1990). Moreover, with the exception of the ISO standard, these indices were developed several decades ago, during the second half of the twentieth century, and have remained unchanged since then. During their development, human-response experiments were conducted under controlled laboratory conditions, exposing subjects to prescribed accelerations, always on land. None of these studies incorporated measurements of the real accelerations measured onboard vessels. As a result, existing indices are poorly suited to evaluating operability losses in specific vessels. These limitations underline the need to test them under real conditions and, if needed, develop a new operability-loss index tailored specifically to small and medium-sized vessels. This work presents preliminary results from an analysis of small and medium-sized vessel motions based on continuous onboard measurements. The study integrates data from GPS and Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) sensors to characterise vessel motions during different trips. The aim is to identify the most relevant components of motion and examine their influence on crew welfare and operational performance. In addition to the motion analysis, the study considers the crew motion incidence perception. Specifically, the crew's perception of the effects that motions have on onboard tasks is studied. A link between physical motion data and real operational impact is established by correlating the measured IMU accelerations with the crew’s subjective accounts of discomfort, difficulty, or interruption. The key parameters considered include the amplitude, frequency, and duration of vertical and lateral accelerations, as they strongly affect the crew’s ability to perform tasks safely and effectively. The measured values are then evaluated in relation to the applicability of the onboard welfare and motion-related criteria mentioned above, assessing whether existing thresholds or indices are compatible with the actual accelerations recorded on vessels. The final objective of this work is to derive a set of reference values that can serve as indicators of operability and human performance onboard small and medium-sized vessels, thereby contributing to the development of a motion-based operability index tailored to different maritime sectors. The dataset analysed comprises different small and medium-sized vessels, including different types of vessels and geographic regions. All studied vessels operate in coastal waters, characterised by single-day trips. A defining feature of coastal navigation is that vessels are generally not exposed to extreme sea states. In this context, the present study provides a decision-support tool designed to help crews estimate the potential loss of operability associated with different environmental scenarios. The utility of this tool will strongly depend on the specific characteristics of each vessel, as well as the training, experience, and risk tolerance of its crew. For this reason, a calibration period will be required, based on the crew’s own perception of vessel motions and their impact on daily tasks. Based on these preliminary results, further research will be conducted in upcoming field campaigns. These studies aim to broaden the scope of the present analysis by incorporating a more diverse sample of vessels . Moreover, data will be collected under a wider range of meteorological and oceanographic conditions for each individual vessel. The objective is to capture a more comprehensive understanding of vessel dynamic responses, crew perception, and operational behaviour across a variety of real-world environmental scenarios.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carrasco-Serra et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: