Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Abstract "Race for the Arctic" and the "New Cold War" are common newspaper headlines when it comes to coverage of Arctic affairs. In popular media, the Arctic is often portrayed as a zone of potential conflict – with unresolved boundary issues, rapidly changing sea ice cover and tempting natural resources forming a potentially explosive political cocktail. On the other hand, the region possesses a strong track record of post-Cold War peace and cooperation and political leaders and civil servants representing Arctic states have, in recent years, become a coordinated chorus extolling the peacefulness of the region. This article illustrates how the Arctic is represented as a zone of potential conflict in the media through a sampling of international media and an in-depth case study of how the potential for Arctic conflict is discussed in a mainstream Russian newspaper. I argue that these different 'framings' or representations of Arctic politics have significance for the kind of politics that can be pursued in the region and discuss how a certain kind of geopolitical reasoning contributes to seeing the Arctic as a latent space of danger and conflict. Acknowledgements The author would like to thank Helge Blakkisrud for great cooperation in examining Russian Arctic discourses in the fall of 2011, the interviewees for sharing their valuable insights, Darya Shut for assistance in assembling Russian media coverage of Arctic affairs and the two anonymous reviewers for thoughtful comments on the article. Notes 1. Others take this argument about reality further and argue that we need to accept that there are multiple physical realities. Nustad (Citation2011) argues that a hunter and a conservationist have such different spatial practices that the reality of the physical space is different as well. Strandsbjerg (Citation2010) argues that space conditions how boundaries can be established and argues we have inserted a 'unified nature' behind what are simply branded 'cultural interpretations' of physical space, which serves to mute controversy over spatial reality. 2. See Megoran (Citation2005) for an interesting study of representations of danger in another region of the world – Central Asia. 3. The analysis of Russian Arctic discourse around competition/cooperation is based on a systematic review of 323 articles on Arctic themes in the conservative, state-owned newspaper Rossiiskaia gazeta between May 2008 and June 2011. These articles were all coded for content in terms of what sorts of Arctic issues were the main focus of the article (cooperation/conflict, shipping, petroleum, climate, research, indigenous peoples, infrastructure etc). The full study of this media discourse is currently under review and available from the authors as a manuscript/working paper (Wilson Rowe and Blakkisrud Citation2012). 4. This is perhaps unsurprising given Norway's extensive bilateral contact with Russia at local, regional (northwest Russia) and national levels (See Hønneland and Rowe Citation2010 for an overview and discussion. See also Moe, Fjærtoft and Øverland Citation2011 for a discussion of the peaceful resolution of Barents Sea dispute). 5. These references generated by an online poll of Arctic experts requesting that they identify recent, conflict-oriented coverage of Arctic affairs. 6. See Zysk (Citation2011) for an interesting discussion of how Russia's foreign policy in non-Arctic settings has set a framework for (mis)interpreting the country's Arctic military activities. 7. See Stokke and Hønneland (Citation2007) for an overview.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elana Wilson Rowe (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: