Key result
Twice-daily 30-second ECG snapshots detect only ~52% of asymptomatic AF identified by continuous monitoring.
Why the study?
The relationship between AF detection rates and the burden of AF found with intermittent electrocardiogram snapshot strategies was unknown.
Does intermittent short ECG screening detect a comparable proportion of atrial fibrillation relative to continuous monitoring?
Does intermittent short ECG screening detect a comparable proportion of atrial fibrillation relative to continuous monitoring?
Absolute Event Rate: 52% vs 100%
Intermittent ECG screening detects roughly half of patients with paroxysmal AF compared to continuous monitoring, but preferentially identifies those with higher AF burdens.
Intermittent ECG screening may miss nearly half of asymptomatic AF cases; leaves open whether burden-stratified detection alters screening yield or outcomes.
AIMS: Screening for asymptomatic atrial fibrillation (AF) could prevent strokes and save lives, but the AF burden of those detected can impact prognosis. New technologies enable continuous monitoring or intermittent electrocardiogram (ECG) snapshots, however, the relationship between AF detection rates and the burden of AF found with intermittent strategies is unknown. We simulated the likelihood of detecting AF using real-world 2-week continuous ECG recordings and developed a generalizable model for AF detection strategies. METHODS AND RESULTS: From 1738 asymptomatic screened individuals, ECG data of 69 individuals (mean age 76.3, median burden 1.9%) with new AF found during 14 days continuous monitoring were used to simulate 30 seconds ECG snapshots one to four times daily for 14 days. Based on this simulation, 35-66% of individuals with AF would be detected using intermittent screening. Twice-daily snapshots for 2 weeks missed 48% of those detected by continuous monitoring, but mean burden was 0.68% vs. 4% in those detected (P < 0.001). In a cohort of 6235 patients (mean age 69.2, median burden 4.6%) with paroxysmal AF during clinically indicated monitoring, simulated detection rates were 53-76%. The Markovian model of AF detection using mean episode duration and mean burden simulated actual AF detection with ≤9% error across the range of screening frequencies and durations. CONCLUSION: Using twice-daily ECG snapshots over 2 weeks would detect only half of individuals discovered to have AF by continuous recordings, but AF burden of those missed was low. A model predicting AF detection, validated using real-world data, could assist development of optimized AF screening programmes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Quer et al. (2020) studied Atrial fibrillation (n=6,304). Intermittent 30-second ECG snapshots vs. 14-day continuous ECG monitoring was evaluated on Detection of at least one AF event. Simulated twice-daily 30-second ECG snapshots for 14 days detected 52% of individuals with asymptomatic AF found by continuous monitoring, but the AF burden of those missed was significantly lower.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: