Key result
Short stature in children leads to an overestimation of obesity when using percentage of overweight, requiring a threshold of 35-40% rather than >20% to accurately reflect body fat accumulation.
Why the study?
It was unclear whether the relationship between percentage of overweight and percentage body fat differs between normal height and short stature children.
Does the percentage of overweight (POW) accurately estimate percentage body fat (PBF) in children with short stature compared to normal height children?
Cross-Sectional (n=427)
Does the percentage of overweight (POW) accurately estimate percentage body fat (PBF) in children with short stature compared to normal height children?
The standard rule of POW >20% overestimates obesity in children with short stature, who require higher POW thresholds to indicate true excess body fat.
POW >20% may overestimate obesity in short-stature children; leaves open whether 35-40% thresholds improve assessment in prospective studies.
Background The prevalence of overweight and obesity has increased, not just in adults but also in children. In Japan, the percentage of overweight (POW) is widely used for the estimation and assessment of percentage body fat (PBF) for children. We examine whether there is a difference between normal height and short stature children in terms of the relationship between POW and PBF. Methods A total of 321 children of normal height (163 boys, 158 girls) and 106 children with short stature (78 boys, 28 girls) were assessed according to sex. Percentage of overweight was used to represent the degree of obesity. The PBF of the total body was examined by dual energy X‐ray absorptiometry. Results According to their PBF, normal height subjects of both sexes were classified as obese if they had a POW of more than 20%. However, short‐stature subjects of both sexes were not classified as obese until the boys had a POW of 40%, and girls had a POW of 35%, respectively. Thus, overweight or obesity is overestimated in short stature children in both males and females with the rule “POW above 20% is recognized as obesity.” Conclusions Percentage of overweight is commonly considered as a good surrogate measure for determining overweight and obesity in children of both sexes. However, this study has clarified that body fat accumulation is overestimated in children with short stature when using the POW measurement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Matsuda et al. (2021) conducted a cross-sectional in Overweight and obesity (n=427). Short stature vs. Normal height was evaluated on Percentage of overweight (POW) threshold corresponding to obesity by percentage body fat (PBF). Short stature in children leads to an overestimation of obesity when using percentage of overweight, requiring a threshold of 35-40% rather than >20% to accurately reflect body fat accumulation.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: