Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Validating the satellite soil moisture products is always an active research topic for the application of the products and improvement of the retrieval algorithms, attracting extensive attention. Nevertheless, seldom existing validation activities focus on the validation of high-resolution soil moisture products at the fine scale. To this end, an experiment was conducted in the middle stream of the Heihe River Basin in northwestern China in August to October of 2021, aiming to validate high-resolution satellite remote sensing products of soil moisture. The paper introduces the design, composite, and preliminary results of the experiment. A soil moisture observation network was established with two kinds of sensors (CS616 and Stevens Hydra Probe) validated against soil core measurements. Several synchronized campaigns were performed, and data were collected to validate the SMAP/Sentinel-1 L2 Radiometer/Radar 30-Second Scene 3 and 1 km EASE-Grid Soil Moisture (SPL2SMAPS) products. Besides, an optical trapezoid model (OPTRAM) and collected Sentinel-2 data were applied to estimate soil moisture and to map irrigated area. Preliminary analyses show that: 1) Steven probes perform best, with an RMSE = 0. 040 m 3 m −3 and ubRMSE = 0. 034 m 3 m −3 ; 2) Both the SPL2SMAPS products at 3 km and 1 km show large RMSE (0. 128 m 3 m −3 for 3 km and 0. 158 m 3 m −3 for 1 km) and ubRMSE (0. 115 m 3 m −3 for 3 km and 0. 158 m 3 m −3 for 1 km) ; 3) The OPTRAM retrievals over bare surface present relatively smaller RMSE (0. 06 m 3 m −3) and ubRMSE (0. 057 m 3 m −3), while retrievals over vegetated croplands present a relatively large RMSE/ubRMSE (0. 083/0. 083 m 3 m −3), and the retrievals can identify the irrigated area at field scale. Overall, the experiment provides fruitful methodologies and datasets for the validation of high-resolution remote sensing products, benefiting the development and improvement of soil moisture retrieval algorithms and products to support irrigation scheduling and management at a precision agricultural scale in the future. • An experiment was conducted and SMAP SM products were validated against measurements. • SMAP products at 1 and 3 km present large errors (RMSE≤0. 08 m 3 m −3). • Satisfied SM were retrieved from Sentinel-2 with R≥0. 62 and RMSE≤0. 08 m 3 m −3. • Sentinel-2 retrievals can identify irrigated extent and dynamics in detail.
Wang et al. (Wed,) studied this question.