Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Sir, In reviewing the influential factors of success or failure in the millennial organizations and higher education institutes that confront numerous challenges, researchers consider effective leadership as the most pivotal factor and the key analyzer.[1] Effective leadership by regulating values and collaborative decision-making processes supports the organization to achieve its mission, vision, and goals and is crucial in creating and shaping organizational culture.[2] However, according to some studies, there is no difference between leadership in higher education or academic leadership and leadership in other organizations, and academic leadership because of its effects on quality of students’ learning is of vital importance.[3,4] In this regard, academic leadership is the result of the influences of a competent leader who creates positive organizational outcomes,[1] directs the organization and its staff to achieve the goals and purposes of the organization, and by gathering a group of staff with diverse mindsets and beliefs under a common umbrella, creates a team. Moreover, the academic leader is the principal agent of sympathy and empathy among the team members.[5] Since 1980s, leadership is focus of attention in higher education, and the concept of effective academic leadership was introduced by Deboer and Goodberg for the first time in 2009.[6] Effective leadership has a key role in higher education, and an effective leader can lead an inadequate program successfully, while an inefficient leader might lead an adequate plan unsuccessfully.[7] The focus of academic leadership in higher education is not only the university but also the setting around it, its educational and research departments, and its specific managerial structures[6] that are prominent in medical universities as well.[8] Higher education in the past borrowed managerial techniques from the private sector to advance its organizational efficiency; however, according to the nature of the higher education institutes, many scholars did not consider management as an effective tool and emphasized on academic leadership that is a complex, multifaceted, and centralized process focusing on individual development.[6] On the other hand, the differentiation of leadership in higher education and in other organizations is the product of exogenous and endogenous factors that is the major cause of the difference between academic and nonacademic leaders who are expected to be more skillful than nonacademic leaders.[5,9] The optimized performance of higher education requires a competent, honest, dutiful leader who has the capacity to influence the university staff and improve the growth and development of its faculty[10,11] while promoting their competencies to protect the university and support its growth. The academic leader must motivate and know how to direct and inspire the institute faculties and staff.[12] In addition, according to the path-goal theory, a successful leader is someone who aligns the personal purposes of its followers with the team purposes and thereby encourages them to be committed to the team and its purposes. However, an effective leader is someone who designs a vision, creates a common power, and directs this power so that the team achieves the organization vision.[13,14] The required competencies for an academic leader include but are not limited to leadership, and communication, persuasion, and professional skills. Furthermore, faculty members have indicated four competencies for academic leaders that include good character, individual knowledge and skills, managerial competencies, and social accountability merit.[10,15-18] Competencies of the future academic leaders of higher education must include adequate skills and acceptable personal characteristics (e.g. flexibility, anxiety control, time management, adaptation management, positive attitude toward others, creativity, honesty, diplomatic spirit, and entrepreneurship); managerial competencies (e.g. decision-making, financial management, teamwork, planning, communication and negotiation skills, conflict management, knowledge management, and power of evaluation); social responsibility competencies (e.g. commitment, sensitivity to cultural differences, demand analysis, and knowledge of economic status); and organizational competencies (e.g. recognizing organizational philosophy and leadership).[19-21] Effective academic leadership uses a combination of charismatic, transactional, and transformational leadership.[5,22-25] Competencies of effective academic leaders include administrative competencies, human and financial resources management, reciprocal interaction, and creating success,[10,26] robust preparation for encounters, appropriate reaction in encountering failures, belief in ethics, risk-taking, scientific superiority, team-making, creativity, courage, justice, and fairness.[15,27] More, they have vision, personal attraction, continuous self-evaluation, encouraging inspiring personality, team-making abilities, mentorship, trial to improve the university performance, emphasis on 360° feedback, and trustworthy integrated personality. Rahimzadeh Kalaleh claims that regardless of discussions about the competencies of the academic leaders, there are limited studies on academic leadership and its features.[8,28] Van Ameijde et al.’s[29] qualitative study on leadership development in universities discussed how leadership in higher education institutes promoted and the other one is Jones et al.[28] who studied about educational leadership and discussed its promotion in higher education institutes.[15] Higher education still has not spent ample attention to the preparation of academic leaders who, like other executive managers, usually understand their new roles by experience, the mastery over which takes a long time. Some studies have estimated that only 3% of universities have invested on training and development of academic leaders such as dean of universities, dean of faculties, and heads of educational departments.[30-32] The process of promoting a faculty into the position of an academic leader is challenging and time consuming and is not successful in all cases. In most cases, dean of universities and heads of departments have no previous preparation, training, and administrative experience about leadership and accept this role without transparent understanding of challenges, complexities, and ambiguities of leadership roles and without prior recognition of the positional changes from being a faculty to being a leader. In addition, they have no understanding and prior knowledge about the professional and personal expenses that must be paid to occupy a leadership position. Although the process of preparation of academic leaders takes several years, managers of higher education institutes know that their growth and advancement from the position of a faculty to that of an academic leader is the responsibility of the education institutes that bring them a higher credit.[30,31] In this regard, investigating higher medical education institutes in Iran indicates that the focus of medical academe is on research and teaching, and administrative tasks receive less attention.[8] Faculty members are trained and motivated for research and teaching, which are the priorities of the promotion and tenure committees. Therefore, faculty members prefer to be focused on their research and teaching competencies, which gains more attention and credit from their workplace. It is contrary to the fact that higher education superior performance requires competent, honest, dutiful leaders who have the capacity to influence the university staff and improve the growth and development of faculty members and their institute.[10,32] Conclusion Finally, this synopsis indicates that regardless of discussions on the competencies of academic leaders in the literature, studies on academic leadership are scarce. In addition, there is no proposed strategy to train academic leaders at various levels. At last, it is emphasized that the future belongs to universities which has a meticulous, consistent strategic plan for the preparation of effective academic leaders as a crucial part of their mission.[8,9] Limitation of the study According to this study, because there is no suggested strategy for training academic leaders at different levels, this factor can limit the precise and coherent strategic plan for preparing effective academic leaders as an important part of the missions in this field. Ethical statement This study did not have any involvement or interaction with human or animal subjects. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nodooshan et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: