Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Why 'writing off the beaten track'?Even if you are not an outright bibliophile, you (and many other avid readers of learned books) may have experienced the serendipity involved in walking down an alleyway in a new city and finding an antiquarian bookshop, pushing the door open and entering the shop, savouring the unmistakable odour of pre-loved, aged books, letting your eyes wander from shelf to shelf and, suddenly, stumbling upon a book that for some (perhaps unconscious) reason sticks out and beckons to be read.You take the book from the shelf; you open it, skim the table of contents, move quickly to the opening page, and start to read.The book instantly enthrals you with the wonderful magic that only words can conjure; you forget about time and place and vanish into the well-phrased investigation that the book generously offers.Not rarely do such experiences come about due to kinds of writing that one has not hitherto encounteredthat is, writing off the beaten track.On the other hand, and in stark contrast to the romanticised opening of our editorial, we all know the feeling of reading an academic text that drags us down and gets increasingly boring.We invariably zone out, become unfocused and gradually lose interest in the text at hand.Perhaps we become frustrated and disappointed at having spent M. H.-L. Laugesen & C. Wegener: Editorial Qualitative Studies 8(1), pp.1-15 ©2023 2 well over an hour of our finite life on such uninspiring and non-urgent writing.Perhaps we push stubbornly on and finish the text because we are intrigued by the contentthe theoretical observations, the empirical findings and/or the practical implications of the work.Perhaps we read the piece to the very end because we want to make use of it in one of our own writings, even if the reading experience is itself uninspiring.Under different circumstances we all react differently, but one thing we must all be presumed to have in common: we would all like always to be reading good academic texts (see Caulley 2008).The big question then becomes: what constitutes good academic writing?For one thing, the goodness of academic texts can stem from various sources.It can stem from the quality of the content of the text: "These findings are so exciting!".It can stem from the quality of the writing itself: "This article is a real page-turner!"or "This chapter really gets me thinking!".Or it can stem from a third, fourth or fifth source.What we want to emphasise, initially, is that good academic writing does not follow automatically ifauthors stick to a given list of pre-defined, universal rules of thumb for success in writing academic texts.Good academic writing can be as different in methods, styles and final appearances as species are different from one another in a healthy and biodiversity-rich environment, and as quality-conscious readers we often seek out singular flavours, styles and voices in the texts we trawl for in the ocean of publicationsbe it in online databases or in physical antiquarian bookshops.As editors, we called for writing off the beaten track in order to declare that the kind of writing and theorisation of writing that we wanted to include and exhibit in the special issue is writing that strays from the well-trodden paths of standardised academic writing.Standards exist for a reason: they have proved to work well, and there is nothing wrong with standards when used wisely and in ways that assist what we want to say.However, these standards can be too rigidly applied, they differ greatly from field to field, and they do not always support (or might even contradict) what the authors want to convey and how they wish to convey it.The title of the special issue also draws meaning from the call for radical thinking contained in German philosopher Martin Heidegger's 1950 essay collection Holzwege, which in its 2002 English translation bore the title Off the Beaten Track.According to Heidegger, genuine thinking (Denken) entails radical questioning of the most basic assumptions about what we take to be true and real.Thus, we would like to think that many of the contributions to the special issue do just that: they
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laugesen et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: