Key result
Only 8% of NCAA Division I universities used preparticipation evaluation forms that met all 12 American Heart Association recommendations for cardiovascular screening of competitive athletes.
Cross-Sectional (n=257)
Yes
The vast majority of NCAA Division I universities use preparticipation evaluation forms that fail to meet AHA recommendations for cardiovascular screening, potentially missing abnormalities that could lead to sudden cardiac death.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Most NCAA Division I screening forms fall short of AHA recommendations; leaves open whether standardized forms improve detection of at-risk athletes.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate screening practices and preparticipation evaluation (PPE) forms used to identify, or raise suspicion of, cardiovascular abnormalities in collegiate student-athletes. DESIGN: Phone and e-mail survey. SETTING: National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division I universities. PARTICIPANTS: All 347 NCAA Division I universities were invited to participate in 2010-2011; 257 universities (74%) elected to participate. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Information about the preparticipation screening process was obtained from team physicians and/or certified athletic trainers. PPE forms were evaluated for the inclusion of the 12 specific American Heart Association (AHA) recommendations for cardiovascular screening of competitive athletes from the 2007 AHA Council on Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Metabolism consensus panel endorsed by the American College of Cardiology Foundation. RESULTS: All 257 participating universities (100%) required preparticipation screening for freshman and transfer athletes, and 83 universities (32%) required an annual PPE for returning athletes. The PPE was performed on campus at 85% of the universities, whereas 15% of universities allowed the PPE to be completed by the athlete's choice of physician before he or she arrived on campus. Eleven universities (4%) used the recently updated American College of Sports Medicine 4th edition PPE. Sixteen universities (6%) used the American College of Sports Medicine 3rd edition PPE. The remaining 260 universities (90%) did not use either of these forms. Of the 257 Division I universities, only 21 universities (8%) met the AHA recommendations by including all 12 cardiovascular screening items on their PPE forms. CONCLUSION: The majority (92%) of NCAA Division I universities do not use PPE forms that meet the AHA recommendations for cardiovascular screening; therefore, they may not be effectively screening collegiate student-athletes for cardiovascular abnormalities that could lead to sudden cardiac death.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charboneau et al. (2014) conducted a cross-sectional in Cardiovascular screening practices (n=257). Preparticipation evaluation (PPE) forms was evaluated on Inclusion of the 12 specific American Heart Association (AHA) recommendations for cardiovascular screening on PPE forms. Only 8% of NCAA Division I universities used preparticipation evaluation forms that met all 12 American Heart Association recommendations for cardiovascular screening of competitive athletes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: