Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this chapter we propose a framework for understanding how alliance partners interpret alliance functioning and how these interpretations shape their subsequent behaviors. We proceed from the notion that interpretive schemes have important implications for the evolution of cross-national alliances, impacting upon the management of the problems arising from the cultural conflicts and discrepancies inherent in such alliances. We describe the two fundamental interpretive schemes that relate to sensemaking, that of sensemaking of and in chaos, and examine how an appreciation of these interpretive schemes enable us to better manage cultural conflicts and discrepancies that inevitably arise in cross-national alliances. Our framework makes clear that the two types of interpretive schemes need to be appreciated as interpretive frames that are present among the alliance managers to effectively interact and influence partner firms. Briefly, the two types of the interpretive schemes call for different strategies for developing them. Alliance partners embedded in different national cultures rely on interpretive schemes to make sense of the conflicts and discrepancies that emerge in cross-national alliances. The chapter responds to the need of managers with alliance responsibilities for a framework to help develop the most effective ways of managing interpretive schemes in alliances for productive interactions and performance. In this chapter we analyze the impact of national culture on the dynamics of cross-national strategic alliances. In recent years, alliances have become an important tool in a firm’s competitive strategy. A large number of these alliances bring together companies that have been exposed to different institutional environments. These differences are particularly salient in alliances that have been formed between Western and Asian companies. In a landmark study, Hamel (1991) observed that Asian firms out-learned their Western counterparts, and, in the process, strengthened their competitive position. A classic example of this dynamic is represented by the failure of the longstanding alliance between Borden and Meiji Milk (Cauley de la Sierra, 1995). Borden sought an alliance with Meiji Milk to penetrate the Japanese market. The alliance broke up when Meiji Milk sought to introduce products that were in direct competition with Borden. It appears that the alliance was a learning experience for the Japanese company. When they had achieved their objective, they sought to restructure their relation-ship. The case raises a number of key questions—namely, is this interpretation of alliance failure culturally neutral; that is, does it provide an explanation that transcends the cultural boundedness of either party? If it is not culturally neutral, then how is this failure to be interpreted from the Japanese standpoint? Furthermore, even if the Japanese sought to introduce products in the marketplace that were directly competitive with those of Borden, was this intentional or was it unintentional? Did Borden acciden-tally, or otherwise, act in ways that led the Japanese to lessen their commitment to the venture? In what way, and to what extent, did the actors’ coping ability influence their interpretation of the alliance dynamics? Another well-publicized alliance that experienced difficulty is the alliance between KLM and Northwest Airlines (Tully, 1996). Although the alliance had been making money, the personal chemistry among the top-level Dutch and American executives was less than optimal. As the President of KLM remarked, “It’s the European way versus the American way” (Tully, 1996, p. 65). It is not surprising that alliance managers who have been socialized in different institutional environments interpreted alliance dynamics in radically different ways. There is, after all, no one objective reality; there are multiple realities, with each reality being constructed from the standpoint of a particular alliance partner. The idea that reality is socially constructed (Berger & Luckmann, 1966) and that it is subject to multiple interpretations is widely accepted in organizational theory (Morgan, 1979). In this chapter, we attempt to analyze the impact of national culture on how alliance partners interpret alliance functioning, and furthermore, how these interpretations shape their subsequent behaviors. In recent years, the concept of culture (both national and organizational) has come to acquire an increasing prominence in organizational studies (Hofstede, 1980; Schein, 1996). Debate has also centered on the relative importance of national and organizational culture in explaining organizational behavior. Without entering into the merits of this debate, it is important to recognize that conflicts among alliance partners may stem from, or be exacerbated by, differences in both organizational and national cultures. Some scholars stress the importance of corporate and professional cultures, whereas others highlight the ever-salient influence of national culture, even as they acknowledge the importance of corporate culture (Kumar & Das, 2010; Kumar & Nti, 2004; Sirmon & Lane, 2004). This chapter takes as its focus national culture as the dominant unit of analysis. In drawing upon the insights emanating from national cultural differences we adopt a micro behavioral view for studying alliance evolution, as proposed recently by Kumar and Das. The essence of this view is the recognition that micro behavioral processes critically determine how alliance partners manage the tensions arising from their conflicting expectations. Micro behavioral processes in alliances, as Kumar and Das note, revolve around “issues of commitment, restructuring the alliance, governance structures, and the decision to continue or exit the alliance” (2010, p. 15). The path-breaking work of Hofstede (1980) has sensitized researchers to the importance of national culture, notwithstanding the complexity that is inherent in conceptualizing and operationalizing this variable. Scholars have studied the impact of national culture on cultural value orientations (Woldu, Budhwar, & Parkes, 2006), the dynamics of multicultural teams (Von Glinow, Shapiro, & Brett, 2004), and international negotiations (Lee, Guang, & Graham, 2006). This is by no means an exhaustive list; it is only meant to be suggestive of the kind of work that has been done using national culture as a central explanatory variable. The chapter begins by outlining a model of alliance functioning and then proceeds to discuss how alliance functioning is impacted by national culture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Das et al. (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: