Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Efficient water management is essential for sustaining agricultural productivity as demand grows and climate change intensifies drought risk. Managed aquifer recharge (MAR) offers a scalable means of improving groundwater security but adoption for irrigated agriculture in Australia remains limited due to uncertainty in economic feasibility. This study addresses gaps in prior assessments that have limited treatment of uncertainty and dynamic operating conditions by applying a stochastic decision framework that integrates empirical aquifer parameters, analytical constraints, and time-varying cash flows linked to agricultural production statistics. The method advances cost–benefit analysis by applying global sensitivity analysis and explicitly characterising deep uncertainty in both costs and benefits. A satisficing decision frame prioritising robustness and regret-based indicators is used to support transparent, adaptive investment decision making. Conceptual case studies show reliance on expected values alone can mask substantial downside risk. In the Upper King River, Northern Territory, increasing scheme scale improved expected benefit-cost ratio (BCR) marginally, however, all scenarios exhibited similar downside risk exposure. In contrast, for the Hillston, New South Wales site, outcomes were highly sensitive to crop type and water-purchasing decisions. Producing almonds achieved strong robustness (98% of scenarios BCR >1) with narrow investment regret bounds, while cotton production relying on purchased water saw robustness reduce from 88% to 38% and downside risks far exceed potential upside gains. The robustness and regret metrics reveal the relative economic strengths and vulnerabilities of different MAR supply and crop production options across plausible futures underscoring the utility of decision frameworks that explicitly manage deep uncertainty. • Stochastic, data-driven framework integrates hydrogeological constraints, and models time-varying cash flows to address major gaps in MAR economic assessments. • Robustness and regret-based decision metrics prioritised over optimisation of expected values, supporting more transparent and adaptive investment decisions under deep uncertainty. • Global sensitivity analysis improves cost–benefit evaluation by explicitly characterising uncertainty in monetary costs and benefits. • Case studies reveal strong contrasts in performance drivers; scheme scale had limited effect in the Upper King River, while crop type and water-purchasing choices in Hillston dramatically altered robustness and investment regret profiles. • Almond production remained highly robust (98%), whereas cotton reliant on purchased water showed steep reductions in robustness (88% to 38%) and heightened downside risk, illustrating the economic vulnerability of some MAR–crop combinations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gonzalez et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: