Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Framework analyzes moral accounting using transmutation ratios in the context of relational needs, suggesting systemic interventions.
This paper introduces Transmutarianism, a novel ethical framework that evaluates moral work based on transmutation ratios. These ratios capture the relationship between what an agent absorbs (receives) and what they emit (provides to others) across hierarchically-weighted human need dimensions. Unlike consequentialist frameworks that treat agents symmetrically, Transmutarianism accounts for differential starting conditions. The framework is grounded in Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and compatible with comparative human-needs frameworks, providing both theoretical structure and empirical measurability.Transmutarianism operates as moral accounting: it measures the flow of relational value using economic mechanisms while leaving questions of moral worth to cultures, religions, and individual communities. The framework is designed to replace the practice of moral exhortation of individual agents with distributed measurement of network effects. The Conduit, the agent at the origin who passes through exactly what they receive, establishes the morally neutral baseline from which all transmutation is measured. Because deterministic passthrough is the default, the framework emphasizes systemic intervention over individual moral exhortation: designing environments where neutral processing produces net positive flows. The asymmetry coefficient serves as a cultural control mechanism, allowing different communities to calibrate the relative weight of filtering versus amplification according to their values. This version redefines moral work as a unit-scale isometric projection, so the asymmetry coefficient rotates the iso-moral lines without inflating the scale of moral work and total moral work becomes comparable across calibrations. It adds a power-asymmetry coefficient that raises the standard for powerful agents by shifting their neutral origin up the moral axis, and it generalizes the Conduit baseline to a movable, power-indexed neutral point. It retains the agent taxonomy distinguishing environments, instruments, and autonomous agents, the Chosen Sacrifice Principle grounded in the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the chain-of-responsibility hypothesis for distributed network evaluation, the framework’s agnosticism toward intent, and the moral-work-vs.-moral-worth distinction together with temporal yield dynamics, regeneration scoring, repair pathways, mixed moral provenance accounting, and anti-gaming safeguards from previous versions We present formal mathematical definitions, analyze edge cases, propose measurement instruments, identify unique theoretical separators from existing ethical frameworks, assess empirical support for the framework’s core claims, and establish the framework’s applicability to all autonomous systems, including artificial intelligence agents.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sev Geraskin (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: