Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Engaging analysis of aDNA and narratives about past identities, suggesting a need for careful interpretation.
In this engaging volume, Anna Källén takes on the interplay between aDNA analysis and the stories we tell about the past, within academia and to a wider public.This is not an easy topic, but Källen navigates it with a light touch, without becoming preachy or moralizing.The text flows well, with many personal reflections on the experiences which shaped the author's thoughts.Heavy jargon is avoided, and key terminology is explained.The book's introduction sets out the long-standing entanglements of archaeology and colonialism, showing how all interpretations are situated in the preoccupations of their own time.This is all the more true of the media frenzy around some aDNA-based research.The chapter clearly sets out the tension between aDNA research promising a glimpse of 'true' identities, and actual research practice with its interpretive choices and sometimes conflicting data.The following four chapters each take on one aspect of this uneasy relationship.The first expertly introduces what DNA can and cannot tell us, juxtaposing the messiness of lived identities with the clear-cut answers that many DNA studies purport to provide.In this process, images and imagination play a key role, and drawing this out is one of the strengths of the book.Much genetic analysis offers probabilities rather than certainty, but this remains undercommunicated, creating the illusion of greater reliability.Källén shows that we need to honour ambiguity, insist on the value of different kinds of information, and scrutinize the questions being asked of molecular data.These questions, it turns out, are rooted in some very old narratives.These narratives are taken up in the following chapter, which focuses on culture, history and the visual representation of the arrow on the map.Using case studies from Europe, Asia and the Americas, Källén makes some crucial points: the simplest model of admixture is not always best, scales of analysis must be carefully chosen, and we must be wary of methodological nationalism and of the assumptions inherent in the use of ethnic or national labels (such as 'Dutch') when applied to aDNA-based populations.Publications in aDNA often compress time and geographical distance to create a coherent storyline with purposeful protagonists, transporting many unreflected modern assumptions into the past.These points are not new to scholars familiar with the field, but they are clearly, concisely and convincingly explained.I for one will add this chapter to my undergraduate reading lists.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daniela Hofmann (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: