Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Perhaps the most enigmatic story of a riddle contest in European literature is told in a scene near the middle of Piers Plowman known as the Banquet of Conscience. It draws on a bewildering variety of riddling forms current in the fourteenth century, from the most arcane Latin riddle tricks to popular stories of riddle contests, all of which distill ancient and widespread riddling traditions. The prominence of such materials in one of the poem's most dynamic scenes suggests that the whole scene might best be read as a riddle contest. Indeed, I propose reading it in light of what were probably the two best-known stories of riddle contests at the time, one about a saint and one about the peasant trickster named Marcolf. In Langland's hybrid contest, the contestants become not merely characters but representations of modes of discourse. The winner is the enigmatic mode itself: this scene uses riddling as a form to intensify the poem's focus on a pervasive poetic mode oriented toward open-ended interpretation of mystery. Moreover, this enigmatic mode grows in authority here, on its way to becoming the poem's dominant, most far-reaching voice, precisely and paradoxically through its association with both saints and fools. Langland's scene thus consolidates and extends a medieval tradition of riddle contests, one that has yet to be adequately considered as such by modern scholars. It shows how the play of riddling, when incorporated into larger literary forms, can reach toward the theological implications of the verse that so fascinated medieval thinkers, “We see now through a mirror in a riddle, but then face to face.”
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Curtis Gruenler (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: