Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This essay argues that ‘idolatry’ and the discourse surrounding it played a seminal role in thinking India in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries – similar to the role played by ‘fetishism’ in Enlightenment constructions of African societies. Both concepts stress the inappropriateness of material entities as loci of spiritual and devotional activity. Both concepts were linked to the idea of superstition (superstitio), which in its traditional Latin sense referred to the kind of religious subjectivity which produced exaggerated or excessive, hence superfluous, cult practices. As repetitive, material practices, the latter could be placed on the same continuum as material objects, hence adjudged inappropriate media for spiritual activity. In exploring these concepts and their deployment with reference to colonial India, this essay aims to be a study of mentalities, of etymologies, of subconscious influences and indeterminacies, of subterranean linguistic echoes that framed the colonial outlook. In the context of colonial Indian society, the idolater’s lack of an autonomous subjectivity made him unable to control and govern himself, as he was liable to be held in thrall by manipulating the powers of his imagination. Just as the African fetishist’s belief in the power of things made him seem thing-like himself, and rendered the trade in slaves permissible, the idolater’s situation required the intervention of an external rational power to govern him wisely and rescue him from his own idolatry. The social ‘civilizing mission’ could be recast in terms of a battle against idolatry.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Swagato Ganguly (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: